Unable to bear children, she proposed annulment of marriage so he could start a family. He chose love

Unable to bear children, she proposed annulment of marriage so he could start a family. He chose love
Eleanore and Timothy were met with life-changing news that resulted in Eleanore undergoing chemotherapy and a full hysterectomy.
PHOTO: AsiaOne/Carol Ong, Eleanore and Timothy

For many couples, getting married means settling down and starting a family. 

That's no different for Eleanore Lim and her husband Timothy York James. 

That is, until the pair's plans of growing their family were suddenly disrupted just two months after tying the knot in 2021 — when Eleanore was diagnosed with not one, but two life-altering conditions: stage one endometrial cancer and stage two ovarian cancer — which required her to have a full hysterectomy. 

"I was devastated because we both love kids. Right after our wedding, due to our age, we actually wanted to start [trying to conceive]. But when the diagnosis came, it was devastating for both of us. I broke down," the social worker shared with AsiaOne. 

The then-newlyweds' plans for having children were disrupted by Eleanore's cancer diagnoses. PHOTO: Eleanore and Timothy

According to the 36-year-old, her doctors provided an alternative path that could allow the couple to have children of their own: boosting her estrogen, freezing her eggs and possibly going into in-vitro fertilisation (or IVF) after her chemotherapy — but it would come at the expense of the results of her prognosis. 

"The chances of the cancer being escalated to stage four, because it was just at stage two at that point of time, would be very high. And I think the duration of me being able to live on is about a year," Eleanore shared. 

But despite the risks, she was open to the idea. 

She suggested to Timothy: "Since you want kids, why not we try that?" 

He rejected the idea — with both of them agreeing that Eleanore's life was more important than having kids. 

But that wasn't the only suggestion that the 43-year-old, who is an operations staff member at a halfway house, said no to. 

Not wanting to "rob him of his rights of being a father", Eleanore made "a very painful decision" of proposing an annulment to Timothy — so that he could possibly find someone else that he could have children with. 

Eleanore proposed the difficult idea of an annulment, to which Timothy rejected immediately. PHOTO: Eleanore and Timothy

"It's not an easy decision because I love him a lot," she said. 

But for Timothy, it was a no-brainer. He shut the idea down firmly and quickly.

"I didn't even think about it. Although kids are a very important part of our lives, I always remember our vows. I've never even contemplated it," he said. 

"It was very easy to decide that I choose my wife over having kids. Following that, of course the pain of not having children [would come], but I never had any doubts that I would choose my wife over the idea of being a father. Obviously it's easy," Timothy added. 

To show support for his wife, Timothy shaved his head and remained bald throughout her chemotherapy journey. PHOTO: Eleanore and Timothy

And it was this unfaltering conviction and commitment to their love that helped Eleanore reaffirm their bond in such trying times. 

Eleanore and Timothy at the National Family Festival Carnival 2025. PHOTO: AsiaOne/Carol Ong

She expressed: "I felt very blessed and very relieved that he stood firm. I married the right man." 

To show his support for Eleanore, Timothy even shaved his head before her chemotherapy began, even choosing to remain bald throughout her chemotherapy journey. 

Moving forward

With the plans of having children now behind them, Eleanore and Timothy are choosing to focus on the common dreams and goals they share — such as the freedom of travelling as and when they want, being the loving owners to their pets and continuing to create memories. 

"We have a lot of common dreams, not only children. Children is one part of it, but I think the good thing is, rather than focusing on the dreams that you can't achieve, you focus on other dreams that you can achieve," Eleanore stated. 

The couple's furbabies Bella (left) and Junior (right). PHOTO: Eleanore and Timothy

"We both love pets, so we have two cats. I think it's okay if you can't have children, we can create memories in other ways," she added. 

The couple have considered other avenues such as adoption but have decided to focus their attention on caring for their cats for now.

Real Families, Real Stories 

Eleanore and Timothy's story is one of the many featured at a showcase called Real Families, Real Stories, which is part of the National Family Festival Carnival 2025 happening today (May 31) and tomorrow at Singapore Expo Hall 6. 

The carnival marks the start of the wider month-long National Family Festival 2025, led by the Families for Life (FFL) Council, which offers an array of activities and events islandwide for families. 

Some examples include the FunFam SportFest organised by Sport Singapore's Active Parents movement to encourage families to stay active together; and Gardens by the Bay's Children's Festival, an annual school holiday programme. 

As a signature event of SG60, the festival celebrates the role of families in shaping Singapore's development over the past six decades and highlighting efforts to help build strong and thriving families through various interactive exhibitions, showcases and activities. 

Eleanore and Timothy's story is one of the many shared at the Real Families, Real Stories showcase at NFF Family Carnival's interactive exhibition. PHOTO: AsiaOne/Carol Ong

Eleanore shared that she was inspired by her best friend Vanessa (who also participated in another event organised by the FFL Council) to send in her story for the showcase. 

"Deep in my heart, I want to see how our stories can impact other couples who either are newly married or married for many years, or have gone through a lot of challenges in their lives," she explained. 

As for what she hopes that they can take away from their story, she stated: "No matter what challenges you face as a couple, go through together as a couple. Don't just leave anyone behind, because you came to a union.

"And I believe there's a reason why you decided to come to a union with each other. So it's important to pull through together and stay committed to each other." 

For Timothy, he emphasises that being together with someone means showing up and trying every day. 

"Marriage is a constant effort, really, every day. You gotta put in the work every day, and it's really no joke. After going through what we went through, I think it really breaks us and moulds us, you know, to become stronger as a couple together," he said. 

Read Also
lifestyle
Game for love: Singaporean couple tie the knot at Timezone arcade, where they shared many dates

carol.ong@asiaone.com

For more original AsiaOne articles, visit here.

homepage

trending

trending
    Cambodia calls for ceasefire with Thailand, AFP reports
    'They don't gaslight you': Why some Singaporean women like to spend on these virtual men
    Operation targeting delivery trucks yields 3 tonnes of illegally imported produce from Malaysia
    Vape disposal bins available at 24 locations; users who surrender devices will not face penalty
    Motorcyclist, 23, dies in accident involving lorry near Woodlands Checkpoint
    Company director fined for collecting $112k in kickbacks from migrant workers
    Ghim Moh hawker responds to 'unfair' one-star rating over tray incident, calls reviewer 'petty'
    'It was not how I planned to be a dad': Terence Cao speaks about fatherhood
    Long-time tech executive and Microsoft Singapore managing director Lee Hui Li dies
    Etomidate found in blood of 2 people involved in fatal Punggol Road accident in May: HSA
    Nasi padang chain Hjh Maimunah to introduce colour-coded price labels
    Raymond Lam takes selfies with fans while touring Singapore with family

Singapore

Singapore
    • Ex-inmate featured in documentary on Changi's maximum security prison returns to court to face fresh charges
    • Teenager caught with vapes 5 times sentenced to 2 years at Singapore Boys’ Home
    • Singapore-registered cars must have COE of over 6 months to apply for VEP, says Malaysian transport minister
    • 'Please help us seek the truth': Sister pleads for eyewitnesses after brother dies in accident on CTE
    • 2 arrested for suspected involvement in government official impersonation scams
    • Woman, 64, prevented from being scammed out of $300k by OCBC and police
    • Khatib Camp to make way for housing, with its functions moving to Amoy Quee Camp
    • Unwell firefighter taken to hospital after kitchen fire at Boon Lay flat
    • Singapore urges 'restraint' in Thailand-Cambodia border dispute; calls for immediate ceasefire in Gaza
    • Chemical tank falls into sea off Second Link after lorries collide

Entertainment

Entertainment
    • 'I want to be an independent senior': Xiang Yun on ageing positively and not relying on children
    • Chinese actor Zhang Yiyang revealed to have been executed for murder of 16-year-old girlfriend
    • Coldplay might have exposed tech CEO's alleged affair during concert
    • 'I hope Wang Xiaofei earns a lot of money': Ken Chu scolded for selling products by Barbie Hsu's ex-husband, explains his actions
    • Cai Xukun, I-dle, Jam Hsiao: Singapore concert calendar for 2025
    • Florida police launch medical investigation into Hulk Hogan's death
    • Vanessa Kirby on filming Avengers movie while pregnant: 'The coolest thing'
    • Trump, McMahon and Undertaker pay tribute to Hulk Hogan
    • Grammy-winning jazz musician Chuck Mangione dies at 84
    • Hulk Hogan, who helped turn pro wrestling into billion-dollar spectacle, dies at 71

Lifestyle

Lifestyle
    • Wedding ang bao rates in Singapore (July 2025): How much should you give?
    • From Paris to Raffles Place: Singaporean-founded deli Nonette opens pop-up, here's what you should try
    • Digital nomad in JB: Can Singaporeans really work from across the Causeway?
    • Books Kinokuniya's new outlet at Raffles City opens, features reading room and outlet-exclusive items
    • New glamping experience in Mandai starts in August, here's what Colugo Camp has to offer
    • 'How dare you': YouTubers call out London stall for selling 'fake Malaysian food'
    • Queen Elizabeth's fashion looks to go on display in new London exhibition
    • Cat A COE prices remain unchanged in second bidding exercise for July 2025
    • Singaporeans continue to hold world's most powerful passport in latest ranking
    • Health hazard or harmless hue: Should you be worried about the food dye in your kaya and Thai tea?

Digicult

Digicult
    • Slim, sleek, but slightly too short-lived: Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge review
    • World's best Dota 2 teams to compete for $1m prize pool in Singapore in November
    • China's Premier Li proposes global AI co-operation organisation
    • Elon Musk's Starlink network suffers rare global outage
    • Spy cockroaches and AI robots: Germany plots the future of warfare
    • 'Give a positive review': Hidden AI prompt found in academic paper by NUS researchers
    • 'Report 1 shop, another 10 appear': Hoyo Fest artists on copyright struggles
    • NTU penalises 3 students over use of AI tools; they dispute university's findings
    • Australia social media teen ban software trial organisers say the tech works
    • Disney, Universal sue image creator Midjourney for copyright infringement

Money

Money
    • Up 4.3%: Singapore's economy grew in Q2 despite US tariff fears
    • Britain and India sign free trade pact during Modi visit
    • HDB launches 10,209 BTO and balance flats, as priority scheme for singles kick in
    • US-Philippines trade talks yield modest tariff shift after Trump-Marcos meeting
    • Indonesia to cut tariffs, non-tariff barriers in US trade deal
    • US, China to discuss tariff deadline extension as Trump reaches Philippines deal
    • Trump says trade deal struck with Japan includes 15% tariff
    • 10 best savings accounts in Singapore with the highest interest rates (July 2025)
    • US Senate passes aid, public broadcasting cuts in victory for Trump
    • Beneath China's resilient economy, a life of pay cuts and side hustles

Latest

Latest
  • US diplomats asked if non-whites qualify for Trump refugee programme for South Africans
  • Honduras mandates face masks again as respiratory illnesses spike
  • Trump administration to release over $6.4b school funding that it withheld
  • UN aid chief demands evidence after Israel accuses staff of links to Hamas
  • US, China confront each other on Ukraine at United Nations
  • Two Southwest flight attendants injured after jet moved to avoid another aircraft
  • Taiwan votes in major recall election closely watched by China
  • Netanyahu, Trump appear to abandon Gaza ceasefire negotiations with Hamas
  • Daily roundup: Nasi padang chain Hjh Maimunah to introduce colour-coded price labels — and other top stories today

In Case You Missed It

In Case You Missed It
  • Toddler wanders out of home in Selangor, mauled by stray dogs
  • 'I was embarrassed': Malaysian security guard in viral knockout by MMA coach 'thankful' he wasn't fired
  • Mid-air brawl erupts on AirAsia X flight from KL to Chengdu over loud conversation
  • Robber drops gun and misfires after failed clinic robbery in JB
  • $30 one-off cash handout, petrol price cut: Malaysian PM Anwar Ibrahim announces measures to tackle living costs
  • 'I felt helpless': Female tourist claims she was sexually harassed by ice cream vendor in Turkey
  • Unhealthy air quality in Malaysia, NEA warns of potential transboundary haze
  • School van in JB overturns after hitting uncovered manhole, 16 students injured
  • Thai woman allegedly extorts $15m from senior Buddhist monks over 3 years, gambles away almost everything
This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.