Prosecution grills Pritam Singh on contradictions from Low Thia Khiang's evidence as verdict set for February

Prosecution grills Pritam Singh on contradictions from Low Thia Khiang's evidence as verdict set for February
Workers' Party chief Pritam Singh arrived at the State Courts on Friday (Nov 8) morning for his third day of cross-examination.
PHOTO: AsiaOne/Danial Zahrin

The prosecution questioned Worker's Party (WP) chief Pritam Singh regarding his meeting with predecessor Low Thia Khiang and WP chairwoman Sylvia Lim during his trial on Friday (Nov 8).

Continuing his cross-examination of Singh into the third day, Deputy Attorney-General Ang Cheng Hock highlighted that the Leader of Opposition's recount of the meeting on Oct 11, 2021, which was intended to discuss former WP MP Raeesah Khan's lie in Parliament, did not match the testimony given by Low.

Singh is contesting two charges of lying to a parliamentary committee that was set up to look into the conduct of Khan.

In a police statement taken during investigations, Singh claimed that Low had not given the two senior WP leaders any advice, as they agreed that Khan had to clarify the untruth in Parliament.

However, Low, in his testimony in court on Oct 23, said he had not been informed that Singh and Lim wished for Khan to clarify her lie in Parliament.

Citing this contradiction, Ang said: "My point to you is that Mr Low did, in fact, give you advice, which was that Ms Khan had to clarify the untruth in Parliament, correct?"

To this, Singh responded: "Yes, that was his perspective, but we already had that perspective even before we spoke to him."

Ang then suggested that Low was telling the truth, and Singh had in fact not asked Khan to come clean in Parliament, to which Singh disagreed.

Ang also postulated that Low had put forth the idea of Khan clarifying the untruth in Parliament after Singh and Lim suggested holding a press conference for Khan's apology, before she was expelled.

Although Singh agreed that Low had formed that position, he disagreed that it was because he and Lim had made such a suggestion.

Read Also
Low Thia Khiang wondered why WP 'took so long' to reveal lie, adds Pritam is 'a good politician'
singapore
Low Thia Khiang wondered why WP 'took so long' to reveal lie, adds Pritam is 'a good politician'

'A question of memories'

Ang also asked Singh whether he told Low about Khan's confession to key party leaders on Aug 8, 2021, days after she first told the lie in Parliament.

In response, Singh said: "In my police statement, that's what I said."

"I believe I would have, but I already mentioned I don't recall all the details of the conversation," he added after being pressed further.

Ang then pointed out that according to Low's testimony, the former WP chief only came to know about Khan's confession in August 2023.

"Which is the truth?" Ang asked, which prompted Singh to state that he sticks by his statement.

Ang then responded: "Okay, so he's lying, or you're lying, isn't it?"

Singh then emphasised the "open" nature of his relationship with Low, saying that neither one of them lied, and attributed the mismatch to a "question of memories".

Ang asked Singh if it was fair to say that he was doubling down on his position, to which Singh responded: "I would be doubling down on my best recollection and my belief, yes."

"So in other words, Mr Low must be either lying or has a very bad memory as to what you told him, correct?" Ang said.

Singh disagreed.

Ang then suggested that Singh withheld the information from Low because as he knew how the former WP chief would react to it, to which Singh also disagreed.

Verdict set for Feb

After the prosecution concluded its cross-examination, the defence re-examined Singh for about 30 minutes before stating it had no further questions.

Court has been adjourned until Feb 17, 2025, when Deputy Principal District Judge Luke Tan is expected to deliver the verdict for the case.

The prosecution and defence are required to file their closing submissions by Jan 13, 2025.

Outside the State Courts, Singh told the waiting media that "there's still work to be done", reported The Straits Times. 

The Aljunied GRC MP said he has not been on the ground in his Eunos ward due to the trial, and will resume house visits soon.

"Many of them (his residents) have been very supportive and they said, 'Mr Singh, I'm praying for you.'

"It's very kind of them and I thank them for their support," he reportedly said. 

bhavya.rawat@asiaone.com

For more original AsiaOne articles, visit here.

homepage

trending

trending
    Teenager caught with vapes 5 times sentenced to 2 years at Singapore Boys’ Home
    Boy dashes across Moulmein Road, hit by SUV
    'It was not how I planned to be a dad': Terence Cao speaks about fatherhood
    'I'm so angry': Christopher Lee shares thoughts about son Zed sharing bed with Fann Wong
    'He asked why I was so selfish': Kym Ng recalls emotional conversation with husband about afterlife plans
    'It was the right thing to do': SBS bus captain returns missing wallet containing $2,400, work permit to distressed passenger
    Youth presses knife against boy's throat, forces him to strip to underwear
    Over 280 applications, 0 offers: Fresh grad's year-long job hunt highlights new jobseeker woes
    Police warn of scammers impersonating staff from National Crime Prevention Council
    Smiths Authentic British Fish & Chips to stay open for another 6 months after rental reduction
    Male victim of fatal Toa Payoh fire was known to keep many things, say residents
    'I want to be an independent senior': Xiang Yun on ageing positively and not relying on children

Singapore

Singapore
    • 'Not surprising': Experts on 4-room HDB unit in Clementi sold for $1.28m
    • 'My world came crashing down': Woman shares grief after losing boyfriend to substance abuse, mental health struggles
    • MOM probes alleged fake injury claim by Sumo Salad employee amid police probe into owner’s death
    • 'If you don't buy, others will': Woman lists NDP tickets for $25 each
    • 'Fella really enjoying': Monitor lizard chows down on stingray at MacRitchie Reservoir
    • Ghim Moh hawker responds to 'unfair' one-star rating over tray incident, calls reviewer 'petty'
    • '999-year leasehold?' Redditor is dead serious about columbarium booking
    • 10 motorists nabbed for providing illegal ride-hailing services at Changi Airport
    • HDB launches 10,209 BTO and balance flats, as priority scheme for singles kick in
    • 2 dead in Toa Payoh flat fire

Entertainment

Entertainment
    • Chinese actor Zhang Yiyang revealed to have been executed for murder of 16-year-old girlfriend
    • Coldplay might have exposed tech CEO's alleged affair during concert
    • 'I hope Wang Xiaofei earns a lot of money': Ken Chu scolded for selling products by Barbie Hsu's ex-husband, explains his actions
    • 'There's no one whose kin doesn't die': Jet Li reveals his thoughts on death, why he doesn't attend funerals, daughter being suicidal
    • South Korea police raid offices of K-pop powerhouse Hybe over share probe
    • Doctor pleads guilty to supplying ketamine to Friends star Matthew Perry
    • 'Coldplaygate' united the internet against a common enemy - the rich tech bro
    • James Gunn refused to cut Superman's 'hotly debated' squirrel scene that baffled test audiences
    • Caribbean Guard shares circumstances of Malcolm-Jamal Warner's death by drowning
    • FKA Twigs settles lawsuit with Shia LaBeouf over sexual battery

Lifestyle

Lifestyle
    • Wedding ang bao rates in Singapore (July 2025): How much should you give?
    • From Paris to Raffles Place: Singaporean-founded deli Nonette opens pop-up, here's what you should try
    • Digital nomad in JB: Can Singaporeans really work from across the Causeway?
    • Books Kinokuniya's new outlet at Raffles City opens, features reading room and outlet-exclusive items
    • Queen Elizabeth's fashion looks to go on display in new London exhibition
    • Singaporeans continue to hold world's most powerful passport in latest ranking
    • Health hazard or harmless hue: Should you be worried about the food dye in your kaya and Thai tea?
    • Sylvanian Families at centre of legal battle with TikTok creator
    • Long John Silver's slowly shifts to 24/7 operations, here are 4 outlets now open round the clock
    • Four Star rolls out SG60 celebration with $60 bedframe and up to $600 off sofas and furniture

Digicult

Digicult
    • Slim, sleek, but slightly too short-lived: Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge review
    • World's best Dota 2 teams to compete for $1m prize pool in Singapore in November
    • Spy cockroaches and AI robots: Germany plots the future of warfare
    • 'Give a positive review': Hidden AI prompt found in academic paper by NUS researchers
    • 'Report 1 shop, another 10 appear': Hoyo Fest artists on copyright struggles
    • NTU penalises 3 students over use of AI tools; they dispute university's findings
    • Australia social media teen ban software trial organisers say the tech works
    • Disney, Universal sue image creator Midjourney for copyright infringement
    • Initiative by IMDA, AI Verify Foundation tests AI accuracy, trustworthiness in real-world scenarios
    • Under siege? Helldivers 2's latest city to be invaded by aliens could be spoof of Singapore

Money

Money
    • Up 4.3%: Singapore's economy grew in Q2 despite US tariff fears
    • US-Philippines trade talks yield modest tariff shift after Trump-Marcos meeting
    • Indonesia to cut tariffs, non-tariff barriers in US trade deal
    • US, China to discuss tariff deadline extension as Trump reaches Philippines deal
    • Trump says trade deal struck with Japan includes 15% tariff
    • 10 best savings accounts in Singapore with the highest interest rates (July 2025)
    • US Senate passes aid, public broadcasting cuts in victory for Trump
    • Beneath China's resilient economy, a life of pay cuts and side hustles
    • France's PM wants to scrap 2 public holidays to help fix government finances
    • Retiring OCBC chief Helen Wong drives synergies among markets, business units, bank insiders say

Latest

Latest
  • 6 college students in China drown after falling into mine
  • 'I was embarrassed': Malaysian security guard in viral knockout by MMA coach 'thankful' he wasn't fired
  • Severe floods triggered by storm Wipha kill at least 3 in Vietnam's Nghe An
  • Brazil to join South Africa's Gaza genocide case against Israel at ICJ
  • Gaza facing man-made 'mass starvation', says WHO's Tedros
  • French president Macron sues right-wing podcaster over claim France's first lady was born male
  • Israeli police investigate woman over suspected plot to kill Netanyahu
  • Mussolini's great-grandson hopes skills on football pitch outweigh family name
  • Russia, Ukraine discuss more POW swaps; no deal on ceasefire or leaders' meeting

In Case You Missed It

In Case You Missed It
  • 'I felt helpless': Female tourist claims she was sexually harassed by ice cream vendor in Turkey
  • Unhealthy air quality in Malaysia, NEA warns of potential transboundary haze
  • School van in JB overturns after hitting uncovered manhole, 16 students injured
  • Thai woman allegedly extorts $15m from senior Buddhist monks over 3 years, gambles away almost everything
  • I lost my daughter to Kpod addiction: Father of 19-year-old shares heartbreak and lessons
  • China mum jailed for selling 2 sons for over $14k to tip livestreamers, buy clothes
  • Organised crime groups pushing drug-laced vapes in Asia including Singapore: UN
  • Malaysian man strikes $4m lottery after betting on his, girlfriend's IC numbers for 3 years
  • Singaporean who defaulted on NS obligations used fake Malaysian passports at checkpoints over 800 times
This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.