Award Banner
Award Banner

'So quiet': Businesses in JB say fewer Singaporeans there after VEP rule kicked in

'So quiet': Businesses in JB say fewer Singaporeans there after VEP rule kicked in
Quieter crowds seen at the popular Pasar Karat night market near Johor Bahru city centre on Oct 4.
PHOTO: The Straits Times

JOHOR BAHRU - Mr Chan Wah Heng decided to step away from his usual spot at the cash register and could be heard calling out to potential patrons to stop for brunch at his bak kut teh and seafood joint on Oct 5.

The owner of Wah Heng Bak Kut Teh, located next to the popular shopping mall KSL City in Johor Bahru, had felt something was amiss throughout the week as his restaurant was quieter, with fewer meals served.

"It was really weird. The week was so quiet," Mr Chan, 60, told The Straits Times. He has since realised that the slump in footfall was caused by fewer Singaporeans driving into JB after the new Vehicle Entry Permit (VEP) rule kicked in on Oct 1.

Many Singaporeans had avoided entering Malaysia via the two land crossings over the last few days, with 20 per cent fewer vehicles entering from Singapore on Oct 1, The Star newspaper quoted a Home Ministry official as saying.

The good news is that Malaysia has delayed the strict implementation of the VEP regulation as the authorities rush to ensure that more owners of Singapore-registered vehicles get their permits, issuing errant drivers with only a written warning to do so.

"The authorities already said that they won't issue any fines, so more must be done to tell them (Singaporeans) to not worry too much," Mr Chan said, adding that 70 per cent of his customers are Singaporean.

Mr Chan Wah Heng, owner of Wah Heng Bak Kut Teh, said there was a drop in footfall at his restaurant throughout the week.
​​​​​​PHOTO: The Straits Times

The VEP, which comes with a radio frequency identification (RFID) tag, allows the Malaysian authorities to identify foreign-registered vehicles, enabling them to track traffic offences and outstanding summonses.

Some 20 shopkeepers and mall visitors in JB whom ST spoke to between Oct 3 and 5 said there had been a noticeable drop in footfall over the last few days.

Ms Mei Wong, 30, a retail manager selling travel luggage in KSL City mall, said she was also feeling the pinch. She had sold only one set of wheeled suitcases by noon on Oct 5, compared with selling about 30 pieces of luggage daily in the previous week.

"At this rate, it's tough to reach break-even on the rent," she said. Her company had rented a large space on the ground floor of the mall until November.

Quieter crowds at popular shopping district near KSL City Mall in downtown Johor Bahru.
PHOTO: The Straits Times

SSI Maju Express car wash worker Muhammad Rabin said he is worried that he may not get his usual daily wages at the end of Oct 5. His team of three men had managed to secure only one client in the lot behind KSL City, and the clock was quickly ticking towards noon.

"We need to hit about 30 cars a day to get our salary plus commission of about RM60 (S$18.50)," said the 26-year-old.

Interviews with business owners and visitors at several shopping districts popular with Singaporeans found that some of the crowd appeared to have returned, but shopkeepers say the vibe on Oct 4 was significantly quieter than in previous pre-weekend evenings.

Car wash workers waiting for business amid quieter crowds near KSL City Mall in downtown Johor Bahru.
PHOTO: The Straits Times

Stall operators at Pasar Karat, a night flea market, said they have suffered a 30 to 40 per cent plunge in sales since Oct 1. When asked if he knew about the VEP rules, clothes seller Faizal Abdullah said: "Maybe that's why it's been weirdly quiet."

A waiter at Made on Monday, a late-night cafe some 5km from the city centre in Jalan Abdul Samad 1, said that the empty tables on Oct 4 evening was "extremely unusual".

Singaporeans, he said, tend to come in waves from 9pm, and they would queue to get a seat to enjoy coffee and Italian food, and to smoke shisha, flavoured tobacco smoked through a pipe.

Stall operators at Pasar Karat, a night flea market, said they have suffered a 30 to 40 per cent plunge in sales since Oct 1.
PHOTO: The Straits Times

On Oct 5 evening, live camera feed of the Causeway and Second Link in Tuas from the Land Transport Authority's (LTA) One Motoring website showed a long line of vehicles queueing up to enter JB.

But it still looked to be shorter than the snaking lines often seen on weekends.

Checks using the Beat The Jam app showed the average waiting time at the Causeway was around 50 minutes throughout the morning from 7am. The average waiting time was still 50 minutes at around 6pm.

Several Singapore shoppers told ST on Oct 5 said they felt that the visitors from the Republic were back in full force.

At Jalan Dhoby, a street known for its traditional bakeries, long queues were seen at coffee shops and cafes at around 9am.

A 23-year-old Singaporean aviation worker, who wanted to be known only as Ms Chua, said Jalan Dhoby was quite packed and it was hard to book a Grab ride out of the area.

Asked about his view on whether the VEP would deter Singaporeans from entering JB, businessman Lee Wan Choy, 66, said: "Things will eventually square out to be the same as before. And this thing will stabilise sooner or later."

When the same question was posed to Mr Hazeem Esman, 27, a social development officer from Singapore, he said: "I think Singaporeans will still come to Johor with or without the VEP. Nothing replaces the many choices of things to do and buy here."

Meanwhile, queues at the TCsens VEP collection centre in Danga Bay showed no signs of easing when ST visited the area on Oct 4.

Singaporean motorists were coming in with technical issues, including needing to replace their RFID tags and deregister an existing tag.

Mr Saifuddin Zahir, an outdoor adventure consultant, said he queued from 9.30am to around 5.30pm to get his tag replaced.

He said the tag which he received by post on the first week of September and fixed on the headlight himself could not be read at the immigration booth.

"It's quite disappointing for us because the application and registration process was fairly smooth, but at the last stage, when we finally receive the tag and installed it, the message displayed at the checkpoint counter said it can't be read. Now, it's almost back to square one because we need to deregister the current tag and get a new one again."

ALSO READ: VEP warning notices only issued to those who have not yet applied: Malaysia's transport minister 

This article was first published in The Straits Times. Permission required for reproduction.

homepage

trending

trending
    Travel platforms see surge in hotel bookings and searches in lead-up to Lady Gaga concert in Singapore
    RWS unveils lifestyle destination Weave, here are some brands and concept stores to expect
    Bugis hotel employee charged for allegedly molesting female tourist
    Bundles of joy: Edwin Siu and Priscilla Wong welcome firstborn, Tony Yang and wife expecting third child
    Indonesian who flashed SIA stewardess claims he was in 'troubled state' over leaving his friends
    Motorcyclist found dead in South Korea after plunging into 20-metre sinkhole
    Man to be charged for injuring police officer during arrest in Woodlands
    Football academy raising funds for family of Singaporean boy involved in fatal JB accident
    Law Society VP resigns after remarks about rape victim spark outrage
    'We have experienced first-hand the power of cinema': Filmgarde Cineplexes announces closure after 18 years
    Going green this Hari Raya: 6 ways to celebrate sustainably
    From survival to success — what’s next for Singapore’s economy?

Singapore

Singapore
    • Boy, 13, pursues passion with $8 haircuts at Clementi HDB staircase
    • 'I will continue to serve', says Amy Khor after surprise walkabout with PM Wong at Bukit Batok hawker centre
    • 'I am ready to bring the same passion here': SDP's Chee Soon Juan to run in Sembawang West SMC after Bukit Batok SMC removal
    • Wheelchair-bound woman dies after falling into Lower Seletar Reservoir
    • Glycerol in slushies: No adverse effects reported in Singapore, but parents should exercise caution, says SFA
    • Bus enthusiast who sexually violated boys with same hobby gets 16 years' jail and 12 strokes of cane
    • 'Mocking rape survivor offensive and dangerous': Law Society vice-president's remarks on Wah!Banana actor's case draw outrage
    • Blue for seafood, red for meat: Case partners Koufu to have colour-coded price labels at 'cai fan' stalls
    • More than 2 million Singaporeans eligible to vote in next election
    • 'Upskilling [helped me] learn more about myself': Dad of 3 on his mid-career switch into a tech role

Entertainment

Entertainment
    • 'How much time have I got left?' Elton John breaks down in tears
    • Gossip mill: Seventeen's Hoshi and Woozi to enlist in 2nd half of 2025, controversy-hit Kim Soo-hyun said to be attending Taiwan fanmeet, Zhao Lusi reveals hateful message she received
    • Mediacorp radio DJ charged with voyeurism and sexual communication with minor
    • Tay Ying to marry in June, mum Hong Huifang filled with 'happiness, pride and reluctance'
    • Oscar-winning Palestinian director injured in attack by Israeli settlers released after arrest
    • Maria Shriver details 'brutal' divorce from Arnold Schwarzenegger in new book
    • Production on next James Bond film reportedly underway
    • Trump slams Clooney as 'second-rate movie star'
    • Eva Longoria recalls being 'ugly duckling' of her family
    • Conan O'Brien decries 'bullies' while receiving Kennedy Centre's Mark Twain Prize

Lifestyle

Lifestyle
    • Where did all the traditional kuih and snacks at Ramadan bazaars go?
    • Girl boss: She overcame bullying, drugs and bad company to start her own beauty empire
    • From hospital to lifestyle destination: Kada officially opens, here's what to expect
    • Singapore slips in ranking of world's happiest countries, but retains top spot in Southeast Asia
    • 21 places for high tea in Singapore: Updated with 1-for-1 deals (March 2025)
    • 1-for-1 deals and up to 50% off furniture at Four Stars Grassroots' clearance sale
    • On this day in 2015, the Singapore Armed Forces Volunteer Corps enlisted its inaugural intake
    • Inside a rare freehold landed estate in Punggol: Touring Ponggol Seventeenth Avenue (priced from $6m)
    • Trendy Scandinavian HDB room designs for an elegant and aesthetic space
    • 17 iftar spots in Singapore for Ramadan 2025: Buffets and special offers

Digicult

Digicult
    • A $500 wake-up call: How the Samsung Galaxy Ring made me realise my stress
    • Monster Hunter Wilds producer explains how game has remained unique and fresh over 20 years
    • Is it time to get a MacBook at a good price? The M4 MacBook Air says yes
    • China's Baidu launches 2 new AI models as industry competition heats up
    • China's top universities expand enrolment to beef up capabilities in AI, strategic areas
    • International Women's Day: Meet the Singapore women levelling up in gaming
    • US indicts slew of alleged Chinese hackers, sanctions company over spy campaign
    • Meet the women powering innovation in tech in Singapore and beyond
    • Games in March: JRPGs, co-op games and wrestling
    • Australia fines Telegram for delay in answering child abuse, terror questions

Money

Money
    • Giant deal: Malaysian company to acquire Cold Storage and Giant supermarket chains in Singapore
    • China frees Mintz staff in move to soothe foreign sentiment
    • Samsung Electronics says co-CEO Han Jong-hee has died of cardiac arrest
    • China promotes business potential to Apple, Pfizer and other US companies
    • Personal loan versus renovation loan comparison guide: Which is better for your home makeover?
    • 10 best savings accounts in Singapore with the highest interest rates (March 2025)
    • Do high-floor HDB flats appreciate more in value? The data may surprise you
    • Top 20 most expensive HDB resale transactions in Singapore
    • 5 biggest misconceptions about the Singapore property market in 2025
    • Best fixed deposit rates in Singapore (March 2025): Minimum deposits from $500, rates up to 2.90%

Latest

Latest
  • Heathrow Airport fire not a criminal matter, UK police say
  • Secretive Chinese network tries to lure fired federal workers, research shows
  • US visit to Greenland is unacceptable, Danish prime minister says
  • What are the US and Europe doing to counter Houthi strikes in the Red Sea?
  • Signal head defends messaging app's security after US war plan leak
  • Trump team scrambles to handle fallout from Signal chat assailed as 'sloppy, careless'
  • Pentagon's Hegseth in spotlight as officials deflect blame over leaked Yemen chat
  • Trump cuts hit struggling food banks, risking hunger for low-income Americans
  • UAE president and Trump discuss Gaza ceasefire efforts, state news agency says

In Case You Missed It

In Case You Missed It
  • WP will campaign for 'responsible and loyal opposition' in GE2025 to earn seats in Parliament, says Pritam
  • Over $200k worth of e-vaporisers seized; 2 persons helping with investigations
  • Job ad for nun with offer of $5,000 to $11,000 monthly salary pulled after 3 days
  • Goh Meng Seng says PPP will make way for RDU in Nee Soon GRC, given PAP 'unlikely' to field LGBT activist
  • Woman arrested after injuring 3 men at People's Park Complex; chopper seized
  • Community cooling centres, reduced outdoor activities in schools: Govt task force outlines measures to combat heatwave
  • People's Power Party urges public to 'maintain basic decorum' following racist comments against new member
This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.