'Unnecessary': Petition to review Sers turned down by MND, as not many more eligible sites expected

'Unnecessary': Petition to review Sers turned down by MND, as not many more eligible sites expected
The Housing Board had chosen Blocks 562 to 565 in Ang Mo Kio Avenue 3 for Sers in April.
PHOTO: The Straits Times

A petition for the Selective En bloc Redevelopment Scheme (Sers) to be put on hold and thoroughly reviewed has been turned down by the Government, as it does not expect many more sites to be eligible for the "highly selective" scheme.

Most of the projects with high redevelopment potential have already been selected, and thus, an extensive review of Sers would be "unnecessary", said the Ministry of National Development (MND) in written responses to a parliamentary committee handling the petition submitted by Progress Singapore Party Non-Constituency MP Leong Mun Wai in August.

Mr Leong had submitted the petition to Parliament on behalf of five Ang Mo Kio residents, who called for a temporary suspension of the scheme and a complete review of how compensation and rehousing options are provided for affected residents.

The Housing Board had chosen Blocks 562 to 565 in Ang Mo Kio Avenue 3 for Sers in April, and residents were unhappy at having to fork out more money to buy similar-sized replacement units in a less desirable location.

This exercise was not the first time residents affected by Sers had to top up to buy a replacement flat, said MND in its reply to the Public Petitions Committee, citing the 2003 Commonwealth Drive and 2016 West Coast Road Sers exercises as examples.

The eight-member committee, which is chaired by Speaker of Parliament Tan Chuan-Jin and includes Mr Leong, presented a report on the petition to Parliament on Thursday (Nov 17).

The report, which was released to the media, included three rounds of written responses from MND from Sept 16 to Monday.

Responding to various points in the petition, MND said the design of the Ang Mo Kio Sers package and the valuation approach were the same as for previous Sers exercises, and have not changed since the scheme began in 1995.

Only 5 per cent of all HDB flats are suitable for Sers. The valuation for flats acquired under Sers is transparent and performed independently by private licensed valuers, said MND, adding that replacement flats are "significantly subsidised" to ensure affordability.

The only difference between the Ang Mo Kio exercise and previous ones is that two additional rehousing options – a 50-year lease and a lease buyback – were introduced to address residents' concerns, said MND.

Read Also
'I gave them a scolding the first time': Ang Mo Kio residents on HDB officers doing door-to-door visits regarding Sers
singapore
'I gave them a scolding the first time': Ang Mo Kio residents on HDB officers doing door-to-door visits regarding Sers

The committee asked why HDB offered the new options only three months after affected Ang Mo Kio Sers residents were notified of their compensation package.

In response, MND said HDB was responding to feedback and concerns from residents, especially seniors who wanted a similar-sized replacement flat but did not require a fresh 99-year lease.

On top-ups, MND cited the 2016 West Coast Road Sers exercise where owners of 92 sqm four-room flats had to top up $23,000 for a similar-sized replacement flat at Clementi Avenue 1. Owners of 67 sqm or 68 sqm three-room flats had to pay $7,000 more.

Those who opted for a similar-sized flat at the second replacement site at West Coast Crescent did not have to top up.

In the 2003 Commonwealth Drive Sers exercise, owners of 52 sqm three-room flats who chose to buy a larger 60 sqm three-room replacement flat at Tanglin Halt Road had to top up about $5,600.

MND said whether top-ups are needed will depend on whether residents opt to buy a smaller flat, a unit of the same size, upgrade to a larger flat or move elsewhere.

In the case of the Ang Mo Kio Sers exercise, a significant number of flat owners are expected to top up for a similar-sized replacement flat with a fresh 99-year lease as their existing flats have only 57 years left on the lease, said MND. "They would be exchanging an older flat with only 57 years left to run with a new flat on a full 99 years of leasehold and this is reflected in the differential in value."

The committee also asked if the $30,000 Sers grant and other ex-gratia payments could be increased, in line with the increase in Build-To-Order (BTO) flat prices.

Read Also
money
3 implications the Ang Mo Kio Sers has on future Sers

Replying, MND said the quantum of $30,000 remains "relevant and appropriate" today, as it is one of several measures provided to make the replacement flats affordable. These include a generously subsidised replacement flat and other rehousing options – including other BTO flats, the 50-year lease and lease buyback options, said MND.

"The grant must therefore be seen in context, that it provides targeted additional assistance for eligible households over and above a wide array of other options, all of which are designed to keep the replacement flats affordable, according to the means and needs of the Sers flat owners," said MND.

There are no plans to increase the grant amount, it added.

The removal allowance of $10,000 is derived from actual moving expenses, such as the cost of engaging movers at today's prices, which MND said is typically $300 to $500 per truckload.

While there is no renovation allowance, MND said owners may opt for fittings and fixtures under the optional component scheme for their new flat, which can be paid for via their Central Provident Fund account or a housing loan, to reduce the amount of cash needed for renovation.

The petition had also called for a review of the "options of compensation", to which MND said it was not clear what that meant.

"As far as compensation is concerned, the relevant compensation for an acquired flat is the market value of the same," said MND. It added that HDB reviews the benefits package of each Sers site holistically to ensure the policies and benefits remain relevant and meet the needs of residents.

In a statement, Mr Tan said the committee's duty is to "consider, classify and summarise a petition in a form and manner that best conveys all the necessary information in a report to Parliament".

MPs who want to pursue the matter further in Parliament can do so by asking a question or introducing a motion, he added. 

ALSO READ: What new rehousing options do Sers home owners now have?

This article was first published in The Straits Times. Permission required for reproduction.

homepage

trending

trending
    Leaders pay tribute to Singapore's longest-serving mufti, Shaikh Syed Isa Semait, following his death at age 87
    MPs lead Singaporeans on sold-out durian trips across Causeway: 'Maximise the favourable exchange rate'
    Ayumi Hamasaki turns first solo Singapore concert into full-blown musical spectacle
    'I spend whole day teaching him': Differently abled son learns to cook char kway teow as hawker parents battle serious health issues
    Property tycoon Ong Beng Seng set for another pre-trial conference on July 23
    Jail for ex-auxiliary police officer who loaded 1 bullet and accidentally discharged revolver
    Eligible Singaporeans to receive up to $850 cash, $450 MediSave top-ups in August
    Tears, laughter and reunions: 5 highlights from Star Awards 2025
    'Give the award to me first': Marcus Chin says suspense in Star Awards' top 10 popularity awards is bad for his weak heart
    Roblox avatar and lantern: Star Awards 2025 looks that made us go 'huh?'
    Our favourite Star Awards 2025 looks: Who served sparkles, aura and body?
    Singaporean drivers rack up over $17k in fines for VEP violations in 5 days

Singapore

Singapore
    • Body left at hospital linked to JB petrol station shooting
    • 'Intimacy was not anything sexual', says man who drove car with lover's husband on bonnet
    • HDB to launch first BTO project in Sembawang North in July offering 775 units
    • NDP 2025: Red Lions and naval divers to jump at two separate locations in celebration of SG60
    • NDP celebrations headed to heartlands on Aug 10 with mobile column, fireworks and festivities
    • Singaporean man found following 15-hour disappearance, 2 days after wedding in Malaysia
    • Reform Party to leave opposition group People’s Alliance for Reform; 2 parties remain
    • 'Freeloader' women target elderly in Chinatown
    • Fewer marriages and births in Singapore in 2024; greater stability for later cohorts
    • $1.46b nickel scam: Ng Yu Zhi opts to remain silent after judge calls for his defence

Entertainment

Entertainment
    • Christopher Lee, Cynthia Koh, Chantalle Ng among Star Awards 2025 winners
    • 'Keep going, don't give up': Yvonne Lim and Pornsak win All-Time Favourite Artiste awards
    • E-Junkies: Jeremy Chan, James Seah, Zhu Zeliang on realistic 'underground city' film set in Mediacorp's first dystopian-crime drama
    • 'Let's do something fun together': Ayumi Hamasaki gives fan service after missing out on waiting fans at Singapore airport
    • Shane Pow reveals how much his Star Awards outfit from Taobao costs
    • Christopher Lee and Mark Lee to star in new Taiwanese movie No Good! Ojisan
    • Denise Richards and Aaron Phypers split after 6 years of marriage
    • Jon M. Chu to direct live-action Hot Wheels movie
    • Henry Cavill refused to give David Corenswet advice about playing Superman
    • Shakira donates portion of show proceeds to help victims of deadly Texas floods

Lifestyle

Lifestyle
    • Uniqlo to debut Labubu collection in September, here's what to expect
    • Hong Kong's Michelin Bib Gourmand Mak Man Kee Wonton Noodles to debut in Singapore
    • There's 'mum guilt', but what about dads? As fatherhood loomed, one man felt guilt and 'grief'
    • More opportunity than threat: Singapore employees generally positive about using AI at work, Randstad study finds
    • From Singlish-themed cups to T-shirts repping our neighbourhoods: Here are some SG60 collections to look out for
    • From blogger to Singapore's top influencer: Naomi Neo celebrates 1m Instagram followers after 14 years
    • Is it possible to design an entire home in 10 hours? I took up the challenge in one mall
    • Where to get cheap haircuts in Singapore (2025 update): Kcuts, Snip Avenue, Kimage Hairdressing School and more
    • Why more young families are moving to Pasir Ris (hint: it's not just about the new EC)
    • Best hotel buffets in Singapore for breakfast, lunch and dinner feasts

Digicult

Digicult
    • Slim, sleek, but slightly too short-lived: Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge review
    • World's best Dota 2 teams to compete for $1m prize pool in Singapore in November
    • 'Report 1 shop, another 10 appear': Hoyo Fest artists on copyright struggles
    • NTU penalises 3 students over use of AI tools; they dispute university's findings
    • Australia social media teen ban software trial organisers say the tech works
    • Disney, Universal sue image creator Midjourney for copyright infringement
    • Initiative by IMDA, AI Verify Foundation tests AI accuracy, trustworthiness in real-world scenarios
    • Under siege? Helldivers 2's latest city to be invaded by aliens could be spoof of Singapore
    • Honor 400 Series launches in Singapore with first free in-device AI image-to-video tool
    • Home Team humanoid robots to be deployed by mid-2027, $100m to be invested: Josephine Teo

Money

Money
    • Best credit card promotions in Singapore (June 2025): Citibank, DBS, HSBC, UOB and more
    • Japan, South Korea hit with 25% tariffs as Trump ramps up trade war in letters to leaders
    • Trump says alignment with BRICS' 'anti-American policies' to invite additional 10% tariffs
    • Regulators warned Air India Express about delay on Airbus engine fix, forging records
    • Higher seller's stamp duty a 'light touch' to curb property flipping: Experts
    • Trump tax bill averts one debt crisis but makes future financial woes worse
    • Seller's stamp duty rates for private homes raised; holding period increased from 3 years to 4
    • Trump escalates feud with Musk, threatens Tesla, SpaceX support
    • Online groceries in Singapore: Which supermarket has the cheapest delivery fees?
    • Laundry services in Singapore: Price comparison of 8 affordable laundromats (2025)

Latest

Latest
  • Rubio to make first Asia trip as Trump unveils tariffs on host and allies
  • Lula tells Trump world does not want 'emperor' after US threatens Brics tariff
  • Netanyahu says any future Palestinian state would be a platform to destroy Israel
  • Netanyahu meets Trump at White House as Israel, Hamas discuss ceasefire
  • Hopes fade for Texas flood victims as death toll tops 95
  • Survivors grieve, worry about future after deadly building collapse in Pakistan
  • Netanyahu nominates Trump for Nobel Peace Prize
  • Daily roundup: Singaporean drivers rack up over $17k in fines for VEP violations in 5 days — and other top stories today
  • Indonesia's Mount Lewotobi erupts again, spews ash 18km high

In Case You Missed It

In Case You Missed It
  • Boy, 9, has kidney removed after falling at Bukit Batok playground
  • 'We just want our money': Income Insurance shareholders disappointed at failed Allianz deal
  • Buying property in Malaysia as a Singaporean: 6 key restrictions to be aware of
  • 'I thought it was just firecrackers', says eyewitness after man fatally shot multiple times inside vehicle in Malaysia
  • Malaysian dad in tears after 11 children pool together to buy him new SUV
  • Not nominated for Star Awards' Best Audio Personality but Dennis Chew says The Breakfast Quartet 'should be confident of ourselves'
  • Cyclist hit by bullet slug in nature reserve may have tried to cover his tracks from authorities
  • 'I just wanted a piece of nostalgia': Hundreds turn up at adoption drive to collect remaining Yale-NUS books
  • 'Does your gun have bullets?' Malaysian man tries to touch auxiliary officer's weapon at Woodlands Checkpoint, gets jail
This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.