Award Banner
Award Banner

Tale of two cities: Hong Kong turmoil may boost Singapore's financial hub status

Tale of two cities: Hong Kong turmoil may boost Singapore's financial hub status

SINGAPORE - Hong Kong's reputation as a stable financial hub has been shaken by a controversial extradition Bill that prompted massive protests, and its loss might just be Singapore's gain, experts say.

The Chinese territory and the South-east Asian city-state have long vied for the title of Asia's top financial destination, attracting international business from around the world.

But a decision by Hong Kong's Beijing-backed government to introduce a Bill allowing extradition to the mainland sparked concern among the business community and brought reportedly up to two million protesters onto the streets.

Hong Kong's political crisis is "definitely a dent in its reputation", said Mr Lawrence Loh, director of the Centre for Governance, Institutions and Organisations at the National University of Singapore's Business School.

"There will be some immediate benefits (for Singapore)," he added, pointing to reports that tycoons were already shifting money from Hong Kong.

Hong Kong offers access to China and enjoys freedoms unseen in the mainland, under the terms of its 1997 handover from Britain to Beijing.

It has a large expatriate community and prides itself on its reputation as a financial capital in the region.

But its status is temporary - the handover agreement expires in 2047 - and in recent years, there has been increasing concern about Beijing's influence.

A banking source in Hong Kong said the super rich have begun to shift their assets to Singapore, which analysts said is looking increasingly enticing to foreign businesses as the location for their headquarters and key staff.

Companies were unsettled not only by the massive demonstrations, but also by the proposed law, which they feared could undermine Hong Kong's reputation as a safe place to do business.

Opponents of the proposal worry it will entangle people in China's notoriously opaque and politicised justice system, and threaten those critical of Beijing's policies.

"Enacting such an open-ended law by fiat will only drive business to places like Singapore," Mr Richard Harris, chief executive of Port Shelter Investment, wrote in Hong Kong's South China Morning Post.

Read Also
asia
Many in Hong Kong, fearful of China's grasp, flee to Taiwan

'SOVEREIGNTY ON ITS SIDE'

The territory's Chief Executive Carrie Lam has now suspended the Bill, but she has declined so far to fully withdraw it from consideration.

And that uncertainty could mean firms looking for a first-time base in the region will lean away from Hong Kong and towards Singapore, said Mr David Webb, a Hong Kong-based investor who advocates for stronger corporate governance.

"If you are considering doing it (opening an office) for the first time... then you would probably look at the potential for these laws to be resurrected," he told AFP.

Singapore has sought to promote itself as a less crowded, more orderly alternative to Hong Kong, though it is sometimes mocked as dull and criticised for its restrictions on civil liberties.

The media is tightly controlled and rights groups say financially ruinous defamation suits are used to silence critics and political opponents.

"Singapore is not known as a bastion of free speech but it does have sovereignty on its side," Mr Webb said.

The city-state has also built a reputation for a strong rule of law - key in attracting businesses - and a growing number of foreign companies come to Singapore to settle commercial disputes.

The Singapore International Arbitration Centre, one of several similar centres around the world, received over 400 cases last year and has seen its case-load increase fourfold over the past decade.

In Hong Kong by contrast, critics say the extradition Bill is the latest sign that a traditionally sound legal system is being eroded as Beijing seeks to assert greater control.

Still, any shift away from Hong Kong is likely to be more of a trickle than a flood, experts said.

"Investors in mainland China will still prefer Hong Kong over Singapore due to proximity," noted Mr Abhineet Kaul of consultancy Frost & Sullivan.

Mr Loh added: "I do not believe that the uncertainty and loss of confidence has reached a tipping point where you will see the floodgates open."

 

homepage

trending

trending
    'Sometimes he will show me pity': Tay Ping Hui's assistant reveals his quirks, goes on hiking trip with him
    Nearly 10 years' jail for payroll staff who stole $5.7m to fund lavish lifestyle, including $3.7m penthouse
    Jail for woman who livestreamed sex act at HDB void deck and husband
    Singaporean killed in Spain: Prosecution pursues murder charge against Mitchell Ong
    Popular Uncle Lee Confectionery launches vending machine in Woodleigh
    Your job, your rights: What Singapore's new Workplace Fairness Legislation means for you and your employers
    'I would be grateful if I'm still known at 40': Jackson Wang ponders life, fame, happiness
    Hawkers must personally operate stalls to prevent subletting, says NEA after hawker's viral complaint
    Manhattan Fish Market closes last Singapore outlet in Northpoint City
    Nicolas Cage sued by ex-wife for negligence
    'An opportunity to contribute': Fewer fresh poly graduates land full-time jobs in 2024, but here's how this one did
    'Thank you for being part of our journey': Prata Wala announces closure, sole remaining franchised outlet to rebrand

Singapore

Singapore
    • 'Wow, an additional ang bao': Singaporeans weigh in on Budget 2025 announcements
    • Authorities investigating after 4th fire at Kranji recycling facility
    • 'Exceptional bravery': 4 primary school kids lauded for helping save worker with CPR during cardiac arrest
    • SCDF to hire foreigners to meet rising demand for emergency medical services
    • 2-year-old sexually assaulted in pre-school: 4 more charged for allegedly covering up incident
    • Singapore sees spike in speeding violations as deaths in speeding-related accidents rise by 43.8%
    • Chee Soon Juan announces bid to contest Bukit Batok SMC, plans fundraising dinner
    • Keepsake by Ryo fails to deliver orders worth $19k, urges 'compassion' amid health issues
    • 10-year-old girl hurt by pebbles thrown from condo's 11th storey by toddler
    • Truck driver flees in hit-and-run involving 2 motorcyclists on SLE

Entertainment

Entertainment
    • G-Dragon and Elton John to perform at Singapore F1 race
    • 5 new and upcoming shows to watch starring G-Dragon, Lee Dong-wook and Bai Jingting
    • 'I've to legally adopt my own daughter': Actress Shirli Ling shares little-known fact about kids born out of wedlock
    • Ex-Mediacorp actor Dai Xiangyu joins Chinese acting reality show, ignored by Francis Ng
    • Long-awaited reunion: Apink left crying by fans' surprise video in Singapore concert
    • Dylan Wang, Angela Chang, Li Qin and more to attend Yuewen Global IP Awards at Resorts World Sentosa on Feb 28
    • Ugly Betty actor Eric Mabius arrested for battery
    • Janelle Monae to star in and produce adaptation of Tanya Smith's heist memoir
    • Drake gives pregnant fan $40k after spotting her at his concert
    • Argentina court clears 3 accused in singer Liam Payne's death

Lifestyle

Lifestyle
    • Toast Hut reopens at Bukit Merah, no kaya toast on menu 'till further notice'
    • Ahoy! Disney Adventure cruise adds new immersive experiences to line-up, including Duffy and Friends
    • 'I tried to put us on the world map': Chef Mathew Leong on culinary Olympics achievement, hopes to boost Singapore's food scene
    • 'So upset by this': Customers, book lovers lament Kinokuniya's downsizing of Takashimaya outlet
    • I tried chef Mathew Leong's pop-up blending Asian and Nordic fare, and I wish it lasted more than 5 days
    • Hidden for centuries, Chinese treasures finally see the light of day
    • What to do this weekend (Feb 21 to 23)
    • Florence bans check-in keyboxes as Italy acts against overtourism
    • Cat A COE premiums rise sharply in second bidding exercise for February 2025
    • Final curtain call: Cathay Cineplexes to close West Mall outlet on Feb 20

Digicult

Digicult
    • A $500 wake-up call: How the Samsung Galaxy Ring made me realise my stress
    • Monster Hunter Wilds producer explains how game has remained unique and fresh over 20 years
    • Australian children able to bypass age limit set by social media platforms, report shows
    • South Korea spy agency says DeepSeek 'excessively' collects personal data
    • Paris AI summit draws world leaders and CEOs eager for technology wave
    • Prism+ Sentinel Door Lock and Sentry Pro Gate Lock review: Say hello to hands-free convenience
    • Russian TV falls for fake report on DeepSeek's 'Soviet code'
    • Italy says 7 people targeted by spyware on WhatsApp
    • Australia bans DeepSeek on government devices citing security concerns
    • Games in February: RPGs, pirates, and dating household appliances?

Money

Money
    • Singapore's economy grew 4.4% in 2024, beating forecasts
    • DBS to give staff $1,000 special bonus, introduce capital return dividend
    • Singapore company sued by Novo Nordisk over $1.7b hypertension drug deal
    • Trump says unfair to US if Musk builds factory in India
    • Budget 2025: Singapore children aged 12 and below to get $500 LifeSG credits
    • Budget 2025: Eligible Singaporeans to receive up to $800 in vouchers for SG60
    • More CDC vouchers, $500 Edusave top-up: What you should know about Budget 2025
    • Budget 2025: Additional $100 worth of Climate Vouchers, programme to be extended to Singaporeans living in private properties
    • PropertyGuru lays off 174 employees, shuts 3 units to trim operations
    • Beginner's guide to understanding your credit score in Singapore (2025): What is a credit score and is it important?

Latest

Latest
  • Daily roundup: 5 new and upcoming shows to watch starring G-Dragon, Lee Dong-wook and Bai Jingting — and other top stories today
  • Israeli PM Netanyahu says Hamas will pay for not returning Shiri Bibas
  • China's hopes to be Ukraine peacemaker collide with its goals on Trump, trade
  • FDA staffers told that 'woman,' 'disabled' among banned words; White House says it’s an error
  • South Korea police say building case against Yoon for obstructing arrest
  • China military drove away Philippine aircraft near Spratly Islands
  • Students lead Dark Indonesia protests against budget cuts
  • Hong Kong's last major pro-democracy party moves to disband
  • Hope turns to heartbreak for Israel's Bibas hostage family

In Case You Missed It

In Case You Missed It
  • Malaysia to build $786 million integrated property comprising mall, apartments and hotel next to JB-Singapore RTS Link station
  • Man slashed by cleaver in drunken fight near JB checkpoint
  • Third train disruption in less than a week: Circle Line resumes service after signalling fault
  • Car plunges from 3rd floor of Malaysian building after driver accidentally floors accelerator
  • New ICA services centre to open in April, public can self-collect identity cards and passports there from July
  • Selangor mall shooting: Manhunt underway for suspect who fired at janitor, hijacked car
  • WP new faces hit the ground in areas like Tampines and Punggol; party may contest over 30 seats in GE2025: Observers
  • 14-year-old girl, previously missing in JB, found in Penang with 2 'online friends'
This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.