Musk's X Corp loses lawsuit against hate speech watchdog

Musk's X Corp loses lawsuit against hate speech watchdog
'X' logo is seen on the top of the headquarters of the messaging platform X, formerly known as Twitter, in downtown San Francisco, California, US, July 30, 2023.
PHOTO: Reuters file

A US judge on Monday (March 25) threw out Elon Musk's lawsuit against a nonprofit group that faulted him for allowing a rise in hate speech on his social media platform X, formerly Twitter.

US District Judge Charles Breyer in San Francisco said it was "evident" that Musk's X Corp sued the Centre for Countering Digital Hate (CCDH) because he didn't like its criticism, and thought its research would hurt X's image and scare advertisers away.

"X Corp has brought this case in order to punish CCDH for CCDH publications that criticised X Corp — and perhaps in order to dissuade others who might wish to engage in such criticism," Breyer wrote.

"It is impossible to read the complaint and not conclude that X Corp is far more concerned about CCDH's speech than it is its data collection methods," he added.

X, in a statement, said it plans to appeal.

The decision is a blow to Musk, the world's third-richest person, who has for many years styled himself as a free-speech champion.

But since paying US$44 billion (S$59 billion) for Twitter in October 2022, he has faced wide criticism for firing too many people who policed misinformation, and from civil rights groups for allowing more harmful and abusive posts.

Imran Ahmed, chief executive of the Centre for Countering Digital Hate, in a statement said Breyer's decision affirms his group's right "to hold accountable social media companies for decisions they make behind closed doors."

Roberta Kaplan, a lawyer for the nonprofit, said the decision shows that Musk "cannot bend the rule of law to his will."

Musk and X have also faced many other lawsuits, including claims by former Twitter executives that Musk improperly withheld severance, and by vendors claiming they haven't been paid.

Tesla, the electric vehicle maker that Musk runs, has separately faced several lawsuits claiming it tolerated the harassment of workers. It has denied those claims.

Musk takeover not foreseeable

X accused the centre of breaching its 2019 user contract by scraping and cherry-picking data to create false and misleading reports that Musk turned X into a haven for hate speech, extremism and misinformation.

According to X's complaint filed last July, the nonprofit designed its "scare campaign" to drive away advertisers, and caused tens of millions of dollars in damages.

X had argued that the nonprofit was bound by Musk's policy changes, and could have left Twitter if it didn't like them.

Breyer agreed that X's desire to staunch criticism was "entirely reasonable from a business point of view."

But he said the nonprofit could not have foreseen when it signed up with Twitter that Musk would eventually take over and loosen how it moderated user content.

Breyer also dismissed X's claims against the European Climate Foundation, a nonprofit based in The Hague, Netherlands that promotes efforts to mitigate climate change.

X had accused it of conspiring with the Centre for Countering Digital Hate to illegally gather data.

Nathaniel Bach, a lawyer for ECF, said that nonprofit was grateful for the dismissal of Musk's "frivolous" lawsuit.

Musk's own speech has often also drawn complaints.

In November 2023, Musk endorsed an antisemitic post on X that said members of the Jewish community were stoking hatred against white people, saying the user spoke "the actual truth."

Musk has denied being antisemitic and sought to make amends, including in a January visit to the former Nazi death camp Auschwitz in southern Poland.

The case is X Corp v. Centre for Countering Digital Hate Inc et al, US District Court, Northern District of California, No. 23-03836.

ALSO READ: Former Twitter execs sue Elon Musk for over $171m in severance

Source: Reuters

homepage

trending

trending
    Family of police trainee who died in accident reaches out to good Samaritans who stopped to help
    Police officer injured after motorcycle skids on PIE
    Now you can get Springleaf prata in a cup - with curry - from a vending machine
    Female primary school teacher allegedly committed sex acts with underage male student
    Cat A COE prices cross $100k mark again in first bidding exercise for July 2025
    'I could not possibly discard the embryo': Lee Si-young pregnant with second child through IVF months after divorce
    'They were so caring': Woman praises AirAsia staff's response during toddler's in-flight medical emergency
    Appeal hearing for Pritam Singh's conviction, sentence set for Nov 4
    Orh Gao Taproom, popular bar by night and kopitiam by day in Serene Centre, to shutter
    'It's our grandfather's company, we won't sell', says Wong family as shareholders reject GE delisting bid
    Singaporean man found following 15-hour disappearance, 2 days after wedding in Malaysia
    Jurong West homeowner evicts tenant after power bank catches fire and damages flat

Singapore

Singapore
    • NDP celebrations headed to heartlands on Aug 10 with mobile column, fireworks and festivities
    • 'No room for complacency': Chan Chun Sing says public service must continue to innovate in face of rising expectations
    • NDP 2025: Leopard tank which hit traffic light had faulty component
    • Body left at hospital linked to JB petrol station shooting
    • 'There aren't really many opportunities right now': Fresh poly graduate who landed contract role on job hunting
    • SIA flight from Brisbane to Singapore 'experiences technical issue', diverted to Perth
    • Property tycoon Ong Beng Seng set for another pre-trial conference on July 23
    • 'I spend whole day teaching him': Differently abled son learns to cook char kway teow as hawker parents battle serious health issues
    • Reform Party to leave opposition group People’s Alliance for Reform; 2 parties remain
    • Jail for ex-auxiliary police officer who loaded 1 bullet and accidentally discharged revolver

Entertainment

Entertainment
    • High energy, strong vocals: J-pop boy band Be:First makes explosive debut in Singapore
    • Shane Pow reveals how much his Star Awards outfit from Taobao costs
    • Ayumi Hamasaki turns first solo Singapore concert into full-blown musical spectacle
    • Roblox avatar and lantern: Star Awards 2025 looks that made us go 'huh?'
    • Where Chow Yun Fat was spotted at while in Singapore for Star Awards 2025
    • Cast of K-drama Low Life recounts battling peak summer conditions while filming 1970s underwater chase for treasure
    • Christopher Lee and Mark Lee to star in new Taiwanese movie No Good! Ojisan
    • Denise Richards and Aaron Phypers split after 6 years of marriage
    • Jon M. Chu to direct live-action Hot Wheels movie
    • Andie Chen admits 'traces of loss and loneliness' after 10th acting Star Awards defeat

Lifestyle

Lifestyle
    • Singapore Food Festival returns in September, includes SG60 Specials series
    • From Singlish-themed cups to T-shirts repping our neighbourhoods: Here are some SG60 collections to look out for
    • 'It brings out a certain inner child in them': Parkour instructor works exclusively with the elderly to help them keep fit
    • From blogger to Singapore's top influencer: Naomi Neo celebrates 1m Instagram followers after 14 years
    • Sleeping on the job: This company will pay people $7 per hour to nap
    • Chanel shows haute couture in private salon setting at Grand Palais
    • McDonald's launching Chilli Crab Sauce Burger in collab with Jumbo Seafood, also releasing limited-edition Lunch Bag
    • Is it possible to design an entire home in 10 hours? I took up the challenge in one mall
    • Where to get cheap haircuts in Singapore (2025 update): Kcuts, Snip Avenue, Kimage Hairdressing School and more
    • Why more young families are moving to Pasir Ris (hint: it's not just about the new EC)

Digicult

Digicult
    • Slim, sleek, but slightly too short-lived: Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge review
    • World's best Dota 2 teams to compete for $1m prize pool in Singapore in November
    • 'Report 1 shop, another 10 appear': Hoyo Fest artists on copyright struggles
    • NTU penalises 3 students over use of AI tools; they dispute university's findings
    • Australia social media teen ban software trial organisers say the tech works
    • Disney, Universal sue image creator Midjourney for copyright infringement
    • Initiative by IMDA, AI Verify Foundation tests AI accuracy, trustworthiness in real-world scenarios
    • Under siege? Helldivers 2's latest city to be invaded by aliens could be spoof of Singapore
    • Honor 400 Series launches in Singapore with first free in-device AI image-to-video tool
    • Home Team humanoid robots to be deployed by mid-2027, $100m to be invested: Josephine Teo

Money

Money
    • Best credit card promotions in Singapore (June 2025): Citibank, DBS, HSBC, UOB and more
    • Temasek sees $45b rise in net portfolio value to record high of $434b amid global uncertainties
    • Japan, South Korea hit with 25% tariffs as Trump ramps up trade war in letters to leaders
    • Trump says alignment with BRICS' 'anti-American policies' to invite additional 10% tariffs
    • Regulators warned Air India Express about delay on Airbus engine fix, forging records
    • Higher seller's stamp duty a 'light touch' to curb property flipping: Experts
    • Trump tax bill averts one debt crisis but makes future financial woes worse
    • Seller's stamp duty rates for private homes raised; holding period increased from 3 years to 4
    • Trump escalates feud with Musk, threatens Tesla, SpaceX support
    • Online groceries in Singapore: Which supermarket has the cheapest delivery fees?

Latest

Latest
  • China detains female erotica writers in pornography crackdown
  • China hit by floods, landslides and heat as extreme weather takes its toll
  • Daily roundup: Cat A COE prices cross $100k mark again in first bidding exercise for July 2025 — and other top stories today
  • 10 dead after bridge collapses in India's Gujarat, NDTV reports
  • 'Ghost camp': Israeli operations in West Bank push wave of Palestinians from their homes
  • Thailand parliament starts debates on sensitive political amnesty bills
  • Marseille airport closed as firefighters continue to battle wildfire
  • Malaysia calls for stronger inter-Asean trade amid tariffs uncertainty
  • Flash flooding in New Mexico resort town traps dozens in homes and vehicles

In Case You Missed It

In Case You Missed It
  • Woman injured on SMRT bus after bottle thrown at vehicle shatters window
  • Singaporean drivers rack up over $17k in fines for VEP violations in 5 days
  • Long time no see! Sharon Au, Li Nanxing, Yvonne Lim and others return to Star Awards stage
  • Boy, 9, has kidney removed after falling at Bukit Batok playground
  • 'We just want our money': Income Insurance shareholders disappointed at failed Allianz deal
  • Buying property in Malaysia as a Singaporean: 6 key restrictions to be aware of
  • 'I thought it was just firecrackers', says eyewitness after man fatally shot multiple times inside vehicle in Malaysia
This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.