Can you buy a commercial property before you complete your HDB MOP? Apparently yes

Most of us know that when we buy a BTO or HDB resale flat, we are required to stay a minimum of five years as part of the Minimum Occupation Period (MOP), before we can invest in a second residential property.

However, did you know that even before you fully serve the MOP for your HDB flat, you are allowed to invest in commercial or industrial property without any penalties?

Better yet, because it is not a residential property, you do not pay Additional Buyer's Stamp Duty (ABSD) for it even though it is your second property (after your HDB flat).

Besides completed commercial or industrial units, you are also allowed to purchase vacant land as long as it's not zoned for residential development.

Here's what HDB says:

In other words, if you've just moved into your new or resale HDB flat, and you're thinking of investing in a second property while still under MOP, you do have options – as long as the property in question is not classified as residential.

You can choose to invest in that second property, become a landlord and lease it out to commercial tenants, or take over the premises yourself as an owner-occupier, renovate and start your own shop, office or cafe, as long as you apply and get the right operating licenses.

What's more, the commercial or industrial property does not necessarily need to be in Singapore; it could be overseas as well.

Pros and cons of investing in a commercial or industrial property while still under HDB MOP

There are, however, some pros and cons when you decide to invest in commercial or industrial property (while still being under HDB MOP). Here are a few:

Why invest in commercial property?

1. You have additional funds to invest in property, but because you have yet to complete the Minimum Occupation Period on your HDB flat, you are not able to sell your HDB flat or invest in a second residential property.
2. You want to grow your own business and have a stake in its premises.
3. During the five-year MOP, you can rent out your rooms, but you cannot rent out the entire flat until after. If you invest in commercial or industrial property, you can lease out the entire premises to earn additional rental income. Also, the rental yield from residential properties is usually two to three per cent, but commercial properties can provide yields of about five per cent (or even higher).
4. You believe that the commercial or industrial property you're eyeing will appreciate and provide a significant capital gain or inheritance for you and your family in the future.
5. Most commercial properties (usually) have a lower price per square foot compared to residential properties.
6. Unlike residential rental tenancies, commercial tenancies, especially for large commercial spaces, have longer lease terms, like five to six years. This assures a steady stream of rental income for several years to come.
7. If you're taking a bank loan to fund the commercial property, the maximum loan-to-value (LTV) that the bank can loan you is up to 80 per cent of the property value. For residential property loans, the maximum is 75 per cent (for banks).
8. Since this is a commercial property, you do not need to pay ABSD for it. As for Buyer's Stamp Duty (BSD), the rate is lower than a residential property if the value of the property is above $1 million. For example, if you buy a $1.5 million commercial property, your BSD is $39,600, but for an equivalent residential property, the BSD payable will be $44,600.

Why a homeowner may not want to invest in commercial property

• Unlike residential properties, you cannot finance a commercial property with your CPF savings. You will need to pay out of pocket and/ or secure a bank loan. This includes paying for fees like stamp duty, legal, agent commission, valuation and so on. If you're taking the loan as an individual investor, you will be subjected to prevailing regulations such as the Total Debt Servicing Ratio (TDSR), which is currently at 55 per cent. So, if you're someone with a lot of unsecured and secured debt to pay, you may want to hold back on investing first and pay off your debt.
• The final quantum of the bank loan for your commercial or industrial property will depend on what you're using the commercial property for. The bank will evaluate the anticipated returns, potential risk and market situation before deciding exactly how much it is able to loan you. This is unlike residential properties, where the loan quantum is based on the property value and your credit score. The interest rate for commercial property loans is also typically higher than for residential property loans (0.5 to one per cent higher).
• Loan tenures for commercial property are usually shorter, say 20 to 30 years. Residential property loans are usually longer (30 years for HDB flats and 35 years for non-HDB properties).
• When you take a commercial property loan, you are usually locked in for two to three years. If you somehow decide to sell your property during this period, you may incur a penalty fee of around 1.5 per cent. You will also be subject to Seller's Stamp Duty (SSD) for industrial properties (eg. factories). The SSD rates are higher than that of residential properties. For industrial properties, the SSD rates are 15 per cent of the property's value for the first year, 10 per cent for the second and five per cent for the third. There is no SSD if it's a commercial property.
• Even after purchasing the commercial or industrial property, you may not be able to find a commercial tenant interested in renting the unit. With no incoming rent to tide through your investment, you still need to pay costs like maintenance and income tax (which is a flat 10per cent of the property's annual value every year).

So whether you're an investor or a business owner, investing in commercial or industrial property depends on your short-, mid-and long-term intentions, rental yield, appreciation, market conditions and timing.

When it comes to such properties, location and accessibility play important roles as they determine the property's value, yield and demand over time.

Deciding what to buy

Once you've decided that you want to go ahead and invest in a commercial or industrial property, here are some ways you can start:

1. Identify the zone

• Residential-only sites: On the Masterplan, these are highlighted in light orange colour. These are your residential only zones, whether they are HDB flats, condos or landed houses.
• Residential with commercial at first storey sites: These are in light pink and represent buildings with residential floors, but the first floor is meant for a shop or restaurant. Two- to three-storey shophouses with residential levels or sections are classified under this.
• Commercial & residential sites: These are your mixed-residential developments and are in light blue. They are usually shopping malls, hotels or offices with residential blocks above them.

These three types of sites are off-limits to you if you're still living under MOP in your HDB flat.

The ones available to you while under MOP are:

• Commercial sites: These are your retail and office-only sites, denoted in dark blue. They cover Graded A, B and C offices, such as the ones at Suntec City and in the CBD, mom-and-pop shops, convenience stores and so on. They can be buildings with mixed uses like office space, shopping, and cinema, but not residential. They can be multi-storey shophouses purely for commercial use. As an investor, you can invest in a commercial unit and lease it out to tenants for rent. These tenants can run services from a tuition centre, grocery store, supermarket, gym, kopitiam, pet shop, massage parlour, recreation club, entertainment outlet and so on – you basically ensure you have the proper licenses and permits, upkeep the premises, make sure your tenants abide by the rules and collect rent.
• Business sites: According to the Masterplan, there are three types of Business-zoned sites. The light purple ones (not to be confused with the dark purple ones, which denote hotels) are labelled as Business 1 sites. They are intended for clean and light industrial use, such as for public utilities, telecommunications and so on, with a maximum nuisance buffer (eg. noise) of 50 metres. The magenta-coloured ones are for Business 2 sites. These are usually catered for general industry, warehouses and manufacturing plants that may require larger nuisance buffers. Most Business 2 sites are in industrial estates as they handle heavy machinery, shipbuilding, repairs and so on. Finally, the third type is Business Parks, denoted by their teal-coloured zones. They could also be Science Parks, but in general, they are clusters of low-lying office buildings meant for various industries and research.

Anyway, as long as the property you're interested in is non-residential and falls under commercial or industrial, you should be able to proceed.

2. Decide the type of commercial or industrial property to invest in

Next is to choose the commercial property type you're interested in.

Shophouses

Shophouses are rare, especially the conservation ones in touristy neighbourhoods like Chinatown and Kampong Glam.

In Singapore, there are 6,760 shophouses gazetted for conservation, which puts them in the same rarity class as Good Class Bungalows.

This also explains why they command a premium in the market, like this 999-year leasehold Boat Quay shophouse which is selling with a guide price of $18.8 million.

This particular shophouse has three floors, and they're all for commercial use - with a restaurant on the ground floor, an office on the second and a yoga gym on the third floor and attic.

In Aug 2022, a couple made a $3.7 million profit just five months after buying a Kitchener Road non-conservation shophouse.

The couple bought the shophouse for $4.3 million last year and sold it for an 86 per cent profit to a Hakka Association.

If you're looking for something a little more affordable, there are shophouses for sale for less than $1 million. You just need to pick one that's accessible and has a reasonable amount of foot traffic.

Office buildings

While most offices are located within the Central Business District (CBD), you can find offices in the Outside of Central Region (OCR), such as in Jurong East, Paya Lebar, Woodlands, Tampines and so on.

Of course, choosing a higher grade-level office would also mean paying higher prices for it.

[[nid:558995]]

Grade A offices are your high-end offices with the latest technologies, installations and accessibility. They are usually tenanted or owned by MNCs, reputable businesses and large corporations.

Grade B offices are still fairly good offices with sufficient facilities. Some of them are renovated from older Grade A properties.

Grade C offices are bare minimum buildings with near-zero facilities. They are usually older buildings (30+ years old), found in far-flung locations and lack amenities.

While considered riskier investments, some do offer the best potential cash-on-cash returns, if the timing's just right.

Retail

If you're someone who's always wanted your own storefront in a retail mall, it's possible to own one.

For example, one retail shop at Orchard Plaza is up for sale for $568,000, which is not too bad considering it's in a prime shopping district.

You may, however, want to check up on the immediate neighbourhood and what the adjacent stores are selling though.

If you prefer owning and running a shop near where you live (so you can save on transport), search the mall or retail neighbourhood near your home and see if something draws your attention.

Industrial offices and warehouses

If you plan on going into specific industries (like setting up a furniture workshop), or just want to lease out industrial or warehouse space to potential tenants, you can.

To save money, you can go for strata-titled industrial units instead of looking at whole floors.

Once again, investing in these types of properties requires a much longer-term view, as there are Seller Stamp Duty penalties if you sell them within three years.

This article was first published in 99.co.