Deciding between HDB loan vs bank loan? Here's a quick reference

Considering HDB loan vs bank loan is most probably the second thing many first-time homeowners have on their minds, after figuring out where their first home should be.

Overwhelmed with all the jargon and fine print? Don't worry, we're here to break down the differences between HDB loans and bank loans.

Key points about HDB loan vs bank loan

• HDB loans require a smaller cash outlay
• Interest rates of bank loans are highly variable, whereas HDB loan rates seldom change (the current concessionary rate is 2.6 per cent)
• Bank loans had been cheaper than HDB loans for about a decade (that is, until banks here started increasing their rates in June 2022, following the US Fed's rate hikes)
• You can switch from an HDB loan to a bank loan, but not the other way around
• In terms of late payments, HDB is more lenient than banks

Differences between HDB loan vs bank loan

1. Downpayment

A huge advantage of taking an HDB loan is that you'll be able to fork out a smaller amount of cash for downpayment.

Given the September 2022 cooling measures, the maximum loan-to-value (LTV) ratio for HDB loans has decreased from 85 per cent to 80 per cent. You can borrow up to 80 per cent of your flat's value or price, whichever is lower. For the remaining downpayment of 20 per cent, you can use a combination of cash and your CPF Ordinary Account (OA) savings.

On the other hand, the maximum LTV ratio for bank loans is 75 per cent. This translates to an extra five per cent in downpayment.

What's more, five per cent must be paid in cash for the downpayment, with the remaining 20 per cent to be paid in cash and/or CPF OA savings.

2. Interest rates and monthly instalments

[[nid:624710]]

The concessionary rate for HDB loans is always fixed at 0.1 per cent above the prevailing CPF rate. With the current CPF rate at 2.5 per cent, the interest rate for HDB loans is 2.6 per cent per annum.

It also means that your interest rate is more or less locked for the entirety of the loan tenure, so you’re less likely to see any drastic changes to your monthly instalments.

In contrast, depending on the market conditions, bank loan rates are more variable. And this isn’t limited to home loans with a floating rate.

This applies to loan packages that are pegged to fixed interest rates as well. After a lock-in period of two to five years, these so-called fixed-rate home loans follow a floating rate.

So technically, there is no perpetual fixed rate home loan in Singapore.

Bank loan interest rates are mainly determined by these three floating rate benchmarks:

• Singapore Interbank Offered Rate (SIBOR), which will be replaced by Singapore Overnight Rate Average (SORA) by the end of 2024
• Board Rate (BR)
• Fixed Deposit Home Rate (FHR)

Whether you're taking a SIBOR, SORA, BR or FHR home loan, the interest rate is the prevailing rate plus the bank's spread.

"3M SORA + 1" means the interest rate is the prevailing three-month SORA rate, plus one per cent charged by the bank (the spread).

Every three months, when the SORA rate changes, the interest rate will be changed to match the new rate.

This means that if you have a 1M SORA rate home loan, the loan repayment amount will change every month. If you have a 3M SORA rate home loan, the loan repayment amount will change every three months, and so forth.

However, note that SOR and SIBOR home loans are currently being phased out to make way for SORA, with some deadlines to observe:

• March 31, 2022 — six-month SIBOR will be discontinued
• June 30, 2023 — SOR will be discontinued
• Dec 31, 2024 — one-month and three-month SIBOR will be discontinued

Likewise, "BR +0.5" means that the interest rate is the current board rate plus the bank's spread of 0.5 per cent. The difference is that the board rate is set entirely by the bank.

Meanwhile, an FHR home loan is pegged to the bank's fixed deposit rates. So it's pretty similar to a BR home loan as the rate is essentially determined by the bank.

Are bank loans cheaper?

[[nid:621602]]

The historical interest rate for bank home loans has been above three per cent. In the early 2000s, the rate was 3.25 to four per cent, making them more expensive than HDB loans.

However, due to the Global Financial Crisis in 2008, bank interest rates have been at record lows for several years. It was only in 2015 to 2016 that interest rates started going up again, leading to a high of 2.88 per cent in 2019.

But as Covid-19 emerged and triggered a global pandemic in 2020, interest rates dropped again. Rates started increasing again in the fourth quarter of 2021, when three-year fixed rates were at 1.15 per cent.

With the economy recovering in 2022, inflation followed, leading the US Fed to raise interest rates again. Consequently, banks here started hiking their interest rates, going as high as 4.5 per cent for a two-year fixed rate home loan in November 2022.

In short, whether or not bank loans are cheaper depends on the interest rates at the time, especially if you're taking a floating rate home loan.

When interest rates are lower than HDB's concessionary rate (which has remained at 2.6 per cent for the past two decades), taking a bank loan can be cheaper due to the lower monthly instalments.

But when interest rates rise above 2.6 per cent, taking an HDB loan will be cheaper.

Here’s an example.

Let's say you're buying a flat at $500,000. For this illustration, let's assume the valuation is the same as the purchase price.

With an LTV of 80 per cent, the maximum loan quantum for an HDB loan is $400,000, and the downpayment is $100,000.

If you're taking a loan with a 25-year tenure, the monthly repayments will be $1,814.68.

In contrast, if you're taking a bank loan with an LTV of 75 per cent, the loan quantum will be $375,000. And the downpayment will be $125,000. Plus, as part of the downpayment, five per cent of the purchase price ($25,000) has to be paid in cash.

Let's also assume that the loan tenure will be 25 years.

When bank loans are cheaper

When interest rates fall below HDB's concessionary rate, let's say to 1.8 per cent per annum, your monthly instalment will be cheaper at $1,553.19.

When bank loans are more expensive

On the other hand, when interest rates rise above HDB's concessionary rate, for instance to four per cent, your monthly instalment will be more expensive at $1,979.39.

3. Eligibility criteria

Whether you're buying an HDB BTO or resale flat, HDB loans come with stricter eligibility criteria, including the income ceiling.

Income ceiling

If your gross monthly household income is more than $14,000, you won't be eligible for an HDB loan.

If you're applying as an extended family, the monthly household income must not exceed $21,000.

Family profile	Income of Group A (cannot exceed S$14,000/mth)	Income of Group B (cannot exceed S$14,000/mth)	Income ceiling of extended family
Parents* with single working children	Parents with one single working child	Other single children	Total incomes of Group A and B must not exceed S$21,000
Parents* with married child**	Parents with single working children (if any)	Married child’s family**
*Includes widow/widower or divorcee. **Includes applicants buying a flat with their fiancé/fiancée.

Conversely, bank loans don’t have an income cap, so it’s suitable for those with a higher income.

Number of times you can take a home loan

[[nid:621243]]

What's more, you can only take up an HDB loan twice. If you have maxed out on this, you'll need to get financing from the bank.

Residential status

Do also note that to be eligible for an HDB loan, at least one of the buyers must be a Singaporean. This means that for PR households (who are eligible to buy HDB flats from the resale market), they can only take up a bank loan.

Other requirements to meet include:

• Must not have disposed of any private residential property in the last 30 months before applying for the HDB loan eligibility (HLE) letter
• Must not own more than one market/ hawker stall or commercial/ industrial property

4. Loan tenure

HDB loans are capped at 25 years, while bank loans for HDB flats have a longer maximum loan tenure of 30 years. However, the LTV will be reduced to 55 per cent if the loan tenure exceeds 25 years or extends beyond the borrower's 65th birthday.

(Read our guide on LTV limits to learn more about how the number of outstanding home loans you have can affect the loan amount.)

Having a longer tenure can be a good thing, as it allows you to lower your monthly repayments and spread them out. On the other hand, it also means paying a higher interest over time.

5. Refinancing

You can refinance your HDB loan into a bank loan (subject to the bank's approval), even after getting a higher LTV for the initial loan. With a lower interest rate, you can reduce your monthly repayments.

However, you can't refinance your bank loan into an HDB loan. What you can do is reprice it with the same bank or switch to another bank to refinance it.

6. Late payments

[[nid:621715]]

HDB charges for late payments of monthly instalments and reviews the rate annually. From April 1, 2022 to March 31, 2023, the rate is 7.5 per cent per annum. It's reviewed annually in April.

At the same time, they're generally more lenient and open to negotiations for late payments. If for instance you get laid off and you do not manage to pay your home loan for a while, you may approach HDB for an extension or alternative repayments to try and keep the loan going while you're getting back on your feet.

But this doesn't mean you can get away without paying your home loan; you can still be asked to sell the flat and downgrade.

Similarly, with bank loans, your bank can help you work out viable repayment options. But banks are generally less forgiving to minimise their losses. So if you fail to repay your loan at some point, the road to foreclosure is a lot shorter.

7. Early repayment

Another good thing about the HDB loan is that there's no lock-in period, so there's no early repayment penalty. This allows you to pay it off earlier to reduce the amount of interest to be paid and the financial burden on your plate.

But if you're taking a bank loan, it's better not to pay it off early. The bank will charge a prepayment fee if you cut short your bank loan within the lock-in period, since they earn from the interest.

HDB loan vs bank loan: Which is better?

[[nid:615633]]

Ultimately, whether you should go for an HDB loan or a bank loan depends on your financial situation, your level of risk averseness, and your willingness to keep up with fluctuating interest rates.

If you're on a tight budget, HDB loans should be considered first, as there is a smaller cash outlay. The fixed interest rate also gives you a better idea of how much you're paying monthly for your home loan.

It's also more suitable for those who only want to deal with the property loan paperwork once, and don't want to spend time tracking interest rates every now and then.

And when interest rates are down (and the HDB concessionary loan rate seems high in comparison), you can always refinance from an HDB loan to a bank loan.

If you intend to upgrade fast (e.g. sell the flat and buy private as soon as you can), you should consider a home loan that offers a lower interest rate. This helps to reduce your monthly repayments, and minimise the interest eating into your resale gains.

ALSO READ: How to apply for a HDB Loan Eligibility (HLE) letter

This article was first published in 99.co.