Parti Liyani seeks compensation from AGC for 'frivolous or vexatious' prosecution

Parti Liyani seeks compensation from AGC for 'frivolous or vexatious' prosecution
Parti Liyani.
PHOTO: The Straits Times

SINGAPORE - Former domestic worker Parti Liyani, an Indonesian who was acquitted in a high-profile case last year of stealing from her then-employer, is making an unprecedented bid to seek compensation from the Attorney-General's Chambers (AGC).

She is the first person to be making an application for compensation under Section 359(3) of the Criminal Procedure Code, which was introduced in 2010, prosecutors told the High Court on Friday (April 16).

The provision states that if an accused is acquitted of any charge, and if it is proved to the satisfaction of the court that the prosecution was frivolous or vexatious, the court may order a compensation sum of up to $10,000.

In court documents, Ms Parti quantified her losses at $73,100 - including $37,500 in foregone salary, pay increments and "hong bao", and $29,400 for lodging provided by non-governmental group Humanitarian Organisation for Migration Economics (Home).

The group housed her at its shelter from December 2016 until she returned to Indonesia in January2021.

Despite the limit on the sum she can potentially receive, Ms Parti has decided to seek compensation from the AGC instead of her former employer, prominent businessman Liew Mun Leong.

On Friday, arguments before the High Court on the issue of compensation dwelt on legal issues, in particular, the meaning of what constitutes "frivolous or vexatious".

Deputy Public Prosecutor Mohamed Faizal argued that Ms Parti's application must be dismissed as her arguments fell "woefully short of showing that the decision to prosecute was frivolous or vexatious".

Read Also
AGC had sufficient evidence to prosecute Parti Liyani, says Shanmugam
singapore
AGC had sufficient evidence to prosecute Parti Liyani, says Shanmugam

He argued that from the wording of the provision, case law and parliamentary debates, the threshold test to prove "frivolous or vexatious" was extremely high.

He argued that it was necessary to prove that there was "dishonesty or malice" on the prosecution's part.

The prosecutor argued that the case brought against Ms Parti was "not obviously unsustainable or wrong" as there was more than sufficient justification for the decision to prosecute her.

This included the accounts from members of the Liew family and Ms Parti's own admission that she had taken some items without consent.

He argued that Section 359(3) was meant to provide a convenient and rapid route to obtaining compensation which should ordinarily be pursued through a civil claim for malicious prosecution.

However, Ms Parti's lawyer, Mr Anil Balchandani, argued that it was not necessary to prove malice.

Read Also
singapore
Acquitted ex-maid Parti Liyani seeks probe into prosecution

"What the prosecution is attempting to have this court decide upon, when they say malice should be included in the test, is allowing the prosecution two bites of the cherry, one in the criminal court and two, in the civil court," he said.

Ms Parti, who worked for the Liews for nine years, was sacked on Oct 28 2016 while Mr Liew was overseas. She packed various items into three boxes and returned to Indonesia.

Two days later, Mr Liew Mun Leong and his son Karl made a police report after the family opened the boxes which the younger man had agreed to ship to her.

Ms Parti was arrested after she returned to Singapore in December that year.

She was charged with stealing more than $50,000 worth of items, including luxury watches and brand-name bags.

She fought the charges in a trial that stretched over more than 20 days and, at the end, the district judge convicted her but reduced the value of the items to $34,000. She was sentenced to 26 months' jail.

Read Also
singapore
No further action against Liew family by MOM after review of Parti Liyani case

Ms Parti appealed to the High Court.

Last September, Justice Chan Seng Onn acquitted her of all four charges after concluding that the convictions were unsafe.

After her acquittal, Ms Parti sought compensation for losses incurred and pressed on with a disciplinary complaint she had earlier made against the two prosecutors who conducted her trial.

The complaint is scheduled to be heard by a disciplinary tribunal in September.

This article was first published in The Straits TimesPermission required for reproduction.

homepage

trending

trending
    $55k dream renovation turns into nightmare; contractor borrows money from homeowner
    Singaporean woman given 6 months’ jail in Taiwan for stalking singer, threatening her online
    Restaurant Labyrinth to have 2-day collaboration with Culinary Class Wars' Choi Hyun-seok
    'Overwhelming response': Less than 2,000 books left after Yale-NUS adoption drive, June 14 fair open to public
    Pop Mart's new Labubu collection, inspired by convenience store food, to launch on June 13
    Pamper yourself on your next shopping trip with these exclusive deals
    Orlando Bloom undergoes $17k treatment to remove toxic chemicals from his blood
    'You got yourself a customer for life': Woman receives surprise gifts from SIA crew to celebrate her pregnancy
    Durians for $1.95 at FairPrice annual fair this June
    Honda Freed review: Understated small MPV with plenty of plus points
    More seniors to benefit as 3 local banks recognise CPF Life payouts as income proof for credit card applications
    50% savings, bigger house: Shaun Chen shares more on why he moved family to JB

Singapore

Singapore
    • Jetstar Asia ceasing operations: Passengers scramble to seek refunds, travel plans up in limbo
    • Man returns stolen Jinro toad statue to restaurant after CCTV footage emerges
    • Singapore and Johor Regent Tunku Ismail to swop land plots near Botanic Gardens
    • Maids working in households with kids must have immunity against measles: MOM
    • $52k bid for clinic space: Young business owners react, raising concerns over rising rent
    • Police take down over 1,000 malicious IP addresses in Singapore in joint operation with Interpol
    • Students must be more critical, discerning: Experts weigh in on online peer-tutoring channels
    • Teen, 16, convicted of rioting with deadly weapon after attacking victim at MRT station
    • Man who sued late mum's estate gets 38% share of rent for Yishun coffee shop over two decades
    • This 'officer' never sleeps: Geylang Serai market carpark to have digital sentry to keep watch on errant motorists

Entertainment

Entertainment
    • 'Everyone looked at us with pitiful eyes': BTS' Jimin and Jungkook share funny military experiences
    • Put their logo and priced it 10 times higher: Netizens upset exact copy of Enhypen's merch available cheaply on Taobao
    • 'I'm going to die at this rate': BTS' RM recalls struggling with insomnia and self-doubt during military service
    • RM and V discharged from military service, Hybe headquarters decorated for BTS' return
    • Stars harassed: Jungkook's house almost broken into by woman, chauffeur sells Orm's personal info to fans
    • Harvey Weinstein convicted of sex crime amid contentious jury deliberations
    • Disney, Universal sue image creator Midjourney for copyright infringement
    • Beach Boys founder Brian Wilson dies at age 82
    • R. Kelly files motion to be released from prison, alleging his life is in danger
    • Taylor Swift obtains restraining order against man claiming he had child with her

Lifestyle

Lifestyle
    • A taste of home: Burmese friends open cafe in Bras Basah selling authentic Myanmar cuisine
    • 'I'm doing all this from my heart': Senior volunteer on his love of helping the community for almost 30 years
    • Unable to bear children, she proposed annulment of marriage so he could start a family. He chose love
    • Jurassic World, inflatable playgrounds and more: Family-friendly events and activities this June holiday
    • Les Miserables The Arena Spectacular coming to Singapore March 2026, waitlist now open
    • Polestar 3 Long Range Dual Motor Performance Pack review: Sporty electric SUV that's big in performance and price
    • McDonald's and Tokidoki to release limited-edition collectible charms from June 12
    • Hello, oppas: South Korea's steamy musical Wild Wild is back in Singapore this June
    • 20 Father's Day 2025 deals and promotions: Dad dines free, Porsche test drive experience and more
    • More younger Singaporeans are getting Botox and collagen shots. How effective and safe are they?

Digicult

Digicult
    • Slim, sleek, but slightly too short-lived: Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge review
    • World's best Dota 2 teams to compete for $1m prize pool in Singapore in November
    • Initiative by IMDA, AI Verify Foundation tests AI accuracy, trustworthiness in real-world scenarios
    • Under siege? Helldivers 2's latest city to be invaded by aliens could be spoof of Singapore
    • Honor 400 Series launches in Singapore with first free in-device AI image-to-video tool
    • Home Team humanoid robots to be deployed by mid-2027, $100m to be invested: Josephine Teo
    • Ado concert review: Singer without a face ignites fans while in cage with only silhouette visible
    • EU and US authorities take down malware network
    • Google Pixel 9a: The best AI-centric phone under $800 in 2025?
    • Western intelligence agencies warn spyware threat targeting Taiwan, Tibetan rights advocates

Money

Money
    • Best credit card promotions in Singapore (June 2025): Citibank, DBS, HSBC, UOB and more
    • Best bank offers in Singapore (June 2025): Blackpink Visa presale, Lilo & Stitch Hawaii vacation, up to 50% off flights and more
    • World Bank cuts global growth forecast as trade tensions heighten uncertainty
    • Queenstown 5-room loft breaks national HDB record at $1.65m
    • The biggest misconceptions about buying property in Singapore's CCR in 2025
    • 9 best personal loans in Singapore with lowest interest rates (June 2025)
    • Best fixed deposit rates in Singapore (June 2025): Minimum deposits from $500, rates up to 2.45%
    • SG60 Baby Gift: What to expect if you're expecting
    • The surprising reasons some Singaporean buyers are choosing smaller condo units (even when they can afford more)
    • 'Thank you for your hard work': Scoot gives 4.91 months of bonus, shares on TikTok

Latest

Latest
  • Islamic State reactivating fighters, eying comeback in Syria and Iraq
  • China-backed militia secures control of new rare earth mines in Myanmar
  • Wars now displace over 122 million people as aid funding falls, UN says
  • Australian accused of mushroom murders denies poisoning lunch as cross-examination ends
  • Austrian neighbours of school shooter recall withdrawn young man
  • Musk backtracks on Trump criticism after White House outreach
  • Trump says willing to extend trade talks deadline, but says that won't be necessary
  • Filipino families flee Northern Irish home after night of anti-immigrant violence
  • Palestinian boy who lost 9 siblings arrives in Italy for treatment

In Case You Missed It

In Case You Missed It
  • 2 women arrested for theft at Changi Airport transit area within an hour
  • 40 Singaporeans going on 'Single's Inferno' trips to Japan to find love, minus the cameras
  • Mum of 6 who juggles 3 jobs starts free breakfast club for children in Ang Mo Kio
  • Government official impersonation scam: Syndicate received gold bars worth $500k, cash from victims
  • Queues at VEP application centres in Singapore, JB after news of enforcement from July 1
  • Wrong food delivery: Man 'feels unsafe', calls police
  • Malaysian woman apologises to 11-year-old daughter for 'only' spending $300k on her birthday
  • Boy, 4, caught smoking under a Bangkok bridge sent to government-run shelter
  • 'I feel incredibly honoured': Drum major who dreamed of role as teen leads Singapore Police Force Band in centennial celebration
This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.