Award Banner
Award Banner

Tesla braces for its first trial involving Autopilot fatality

Tesla braces for its first trial involving Autopilot fatality
A Tesla Model 3 vehicle is shown using the Full Self Driving Beta software (FSD) while navigating a city road in Encinitas, California, Feb 28, 2023.
PHOTO: Reuters file

SAN FRANCISCO — Tesla Inc is set to defend itself for the first time at trial against allegations that failure of its Autopilot driver assistant feature led to death, in what will likely be a major test of Chief Executive Elon Musk's assertions about the technology.

Self-driving capability is central to Tesla’s financial future, according to Musk, whose own reputation as an engineering leader is being challenged with allegations by plaintiffs in one of two lawsuits that he personally leads the group behind technology that failed. Wins by Tesla could raise confidence and sales for the software, which costs up to US$15,000 (S$20,308) per vehicle.

Tesla faces two trials in quick succession, with more to follow.

The first, scheduled for mid-September in a California state court, is a civil lawsuit containing allegations that the Autopilot system caused owner Micah Lee’s Model 3 to suddenly veer off a highway east of Los Angeles at 65 miles (104.6 km) per hour, strike a palm tree and burst into flames, all in the span of seconds.

The 2019 crash, which has not been previously reported, killed Lee and seriously injured his two passengers, including a then-8-year old boy who was disemboweled. The lawsuit, filed against Tesla by the passengers and Lee's estate, accuses Tesla of knowing that Autopilot and other safety systems were defective when it sold the car.

Musk 'de facto leader' of autopilot team

The second trial, set for early October in a Florida state court, arose out of a 2019 crash north of Miami where owner Stephen Banner’s Model 3 drove under the trailer of an 18-wheeler big rig truck that had pulled into the road, shearing off the Tesla's roof and killing Banner. Autopilot failed to brake, steer or do anything to avoid the collision, according to the lawsuit filed by Banner's wife.

Tesla denied liability for both accidents, blamed driver error and said Autopilot is safe when monitored by humans. Tesla said in court documents that drivers must pay attention to the road and keep their hands on the steering wheel.

"There are no self-driving cars on the road today," the company said.

Read Also
Tesla to recall over 1.1 million foreign- and China-made cars: Chinese regulator
china
Tesla to recall over 1.1 million foreign- and China-made cars: Chinese regulator

The civil proceedings will likely reveal new evidence about what Musk and other company officials knew about Autopilot’s capabilities — and any possible deficiencies. Banner’s attorneys, for instance, argue in a pretrial court filing that internal emails show Musk is the Autopilot team's "de facto leader".

Tesla and Musk did not respond to Reuters’ emailed questions for this article, but Musk has made no secret of his involvement in self-driving software engineering, often tweeting about his test-driving of a Tesla equipped with "Full Self-Driving" software. He has for years promised that Tesla would achieve self-driving capability only to miss his own targets.

Tesla won a bellwether trial in Los Angeles in April with a strategy of saying that it tells drivers that its technology requires human monitoring, despite the "Autopilot" and "Full Self-Driving" names. The case was about an accident where a Model S swerved into the curb and injured its driver, and jurors told Reuters after the verdict that they believed Tesla warned drivers about its system and driver distraction was to blame.

Stakes higher for Tesla

The stakes for Tesla are much higher in the September and October trials, the first of a series related to Autopilot this year and next, because people died.

"If Tesla backs up a lot of wins in these cases, I think they're going to get more favorable settlements in other cases," said Matthew Wansley, a former General Counsel of nuTonomy, an automated driving startup and Associate Professor of Law at Cardozo School of Law.

On the other hand, "a big loss for Tesla — especially with a big damages award" could "dramatically shape the narrative going forward," said Bryant Walker Smith, a law professor at the University of South Carolina.

In court filings, the company has argued that Lee consumed alcohol before getting behind the wheel and that it is not clear whether Autopilot was on at the time of crash.

Jonathan Michaels, an attorney for the plaintiffs, declined to comment on Tesla’s specific arguments, but said "we're fully aware of Tesla's false claims including their shameful attempts to blame the victims for their known defective autopilot system."

In the Florida case, Banner's attorneys also filed a motion arguing punitive damages were warranted. The attorneys have deposed several Tesla executives and received internal documents from the company that they said show Musk and engineers were aware of, and did not fix, shortcomings.

In one deposition, former executive Christopher Moore testified there are limitations to Autopilot, saying it "is not designed to detect every possible hazard or every possible obstacle or vehicle that could be on the road," according to a transcript reviewed by Reuters.

In 2016, a few months after a fatal accident where a Tesla crashed into a semi-trailer truck, Musk told reporters that the automaker was updating Autopilot with improved radar sensors that likely would have prevented the fatality.

But Adam (Nicklas) Gustafsson, a Tesla Autopilot systems engineer who investigated both accidents in Florida, said that in the almost three years between that 2016 crash and Banner’s accident, no changes were made to Autopilot’s systems to account for cross-traffic, according to court documents submitted by plaintiff lawyers.

The lawyers tried to blame the lack of change on Musk. "Elon Musk has acknowledged problems with the Tesla autopilot system not working properly," according to plaintiffs' documents. Former Autopilot engineer Richard Baverstock, who was also deposed, stated that "almost everything" he did at Tesla was done at the request of "Elon," according to the documents.

Tesla filed an emergency motion in court late on Wednesday seeking to keep deposition transcripts of its employees and other documents secret. Banner’s attorney, Lake "Trey" Lytal III, said he would oppose the motion.

"The great thing about our judicial system is Billion Dollar Corporations can only keep secrets for so long," he wrote in a text message.

ALSO READ: US opens probe into 280,000 new Tesla vehicles over steering issue

Source: Reuters

homepage

trending

trending
    Woman flamed by netizens for secretly recording voting process on Polling Day
    'Dog will return soon': GE2025 independent candidate Jeremy Tan wants to contest again
    We may not have won Punggol, but we won something deeper: WP's Harpreet Singh on GE2025
    Ong Ye Kung leads PAP team to victory while elder brother Howard Ong loses in Australia's election on the same day
    10 killed after 4 tourist boats capsize in China, state media reports
    'Teochew dishes with a twist': Ya Hui teams up with restaurant to cook for dog charity
    'Lest you forget, the SDP never say die': Chee Soon Juan says party already preparing for GE2030
    5 affordable condos with unblocked views priced under $1m
    'Extremely touched': Passenger praises PHV driver for providing free treats and well-wishes during ride
    Car crashes into wall at Anderson Sec on Polling Day, 76-year-old unconscious driver hospitalised
    Gigi Hadid makes relationship with Bradley Cooper Instagram official
    GE2025: PSP’s poor showing shows party needs to rethink branding, policy proposals, say analysts

Singapore

Singapore
    • GE2025: Singaporeans living abroad share experience of voting overseas
    • PAP's Gan Siow Huang wins Marymount SMC with 70.70% of votes over PSP's Jeffrey Khoo
    • PAP wins Punggol GRC with 55.17% of votes over WP
    • WP wins Aljunied GRC with 59.68% of votes over PAP
    • 'I'm here to serve': DPM Gan celebrates victory with PAP team in Punggol
    • 'We've done very commendably': WP's Pritam 'proud' despite landslide PAP's GE2025 win
    • No victory parade: Chan Chun Sing emphasises commitment to residents after PAP’s strongest win in Tanjong Pagar GRC
    • 'Clear signal of trust and confidence,' says Lawrence Wong following PAP's victory in his first election as PM
    • PAP's Poh Li San wins Sembawang West SMC with 53.19% of votes over SDP's Chee Soon Juan
    • GE2025: PAP returns to power with 65.57% of popular vote; WP retains 10 seats

Entertainment

Entertainment
    • (G)I-dle rebrands in light of 7th anniversary, sparking mixed emotions from fans
    • Parents thank Park Seo-joon for donation that saved child: 'It was the first time in a long while our family laughed'
    • Red Velvet's Irene and Seulgi, Exo's Doh Kyung-soo, Xdinary Heroes: Singapore concert calendar for 2025
    • 'My acting wasn't going anywhere': Zhang Zetong was close to leaving showbiz before winning Star Award
    • Byeon Woo-seok, Park Eun-bin, Kiss of Life: A peek at their childhood photos on South Korea's Children's Day
    • Billie Lourd's children watch late grandmother Carrie Fisher on Star Wars Day, fans moved to tears
    • Trump plans to hit movies made outside US with 100% tariffs
    • Beyonce sent cease-and-desist letter to drop certain visuals from Cowboy Carter tour
    • US singer-songwriter Jill Sobule dies following a house fire
    • Comedian Russell Brand appears in UK court over rape and sex assault charges

Lifestyle

Lifestyle
    • Local brands like Ann Chin Popiah and Tian Tian Hainanese Chicken Rice to open at 5-star hotel in Macau
    • 'It hurts, losing everything': Mentai-Ya boss closes all remaining stalls after $550k losses in 2 years
    • Kenny Rogers Roasters now has an all-you-can-eat buffet for $28.90++, here's a sneak peek at the menu
    • This new American malt shop along Joo Chiat Road looks like it came straight out of a Wes Anderson film
    • Things to do in Porto, Portugal: A curated 5-day itinerary
    • Buying a walk-up apartment in Singapore? Don't overlook the shops below - here's why
    • Fun for all in Saudi: A guide to exploring the country's best family attractions
    • Tiny island, massive flex: 60 times Singapore topped the charts
    • 5 false ceiling designs that never go out of style
    • Here's where to treat mum this Mother's Day

Digicult

Digicult
    • A $500 wake-up call: How the Samsung Galaxy Ring made me realise my stress
    • Monster Hunter Wilds producer explains how game has remained unique and fresh over 20 years
    • Google Pixel 9a: The best AI-centric phone under $800 in 2025?
    • Western intelligence agencies warn spyware threat targeting Taiwan, Tibetan rights advocates
    • Taiwan says China using generative AI to ramp up disinformation and 'divide' the island
    • Russian court fines Telegram app for refusal to remove anti-government content, TASS reports
    • One Beijing man's quest to keep cooking — and connecting with Americans — on camera
    • Nintendo Switch 2 to launch in June with US$449.99 price tag
    • Games in April: RPGs, racing and Ronaldo in a fighting game
    • Is it time to get a MacBook at a good price? The M4 MacBook Air says yes

Money

Money
    • Giant deal: Malaysian company to acquire Cold Storage and Giant supermarket chains in Singapore
    • Do high floors equal to high returns? Let's unpack the numbers
    • What DIY property buyers in Singapore might miss out on (and why it matters)
    • How tariffs could shape interest rates in 2025: What Trump's 'Liberation Day' means for Singapore home loans
    • GM delays investor call, UPS axes 20k jobs as Trump's tariffs create corporate chaos
    • India prepared to 'future-proof' trade deal as sweetener in US talks, sources say
    • UPS cuts 20,000 jobs, GM delays investor call as Trump's tariffs create corporate chaos
    • Profit warnings and uncertainty as Trump tariffs send a chill through businesses
    • Risk of global economic recession surges on US tariff shockwaves
    • World military spending hits $3.6 trillion in record 2024 surge

Latest

Latest
  • Copper cable thefts in Spain leave passengers trapped in trains overnight
  • Daily roundup: Woman flamed by netizens for secretly recording voting process on Polling Day — and other top stories today
  • Yemen's Houthis announce campaign targeting Israeli airports
  • With militaries upgraded, risks multiply in any potential India-Pakistan conflict
  • The influencer election that wasn't: Amid Trump trauma, Australian voters logged off
  • Papal contender Parolin is a soft-spoken, longtime Vatican diplomat
  • Israeli cabinet approves expansion of Gaza offensive, broadcaster Kan reports
  • Adani reps meet Trump officials in push to end US bribery cases, Bloomberg News reports
  • Trump orders reopening of Alcatraz prison

In Case You Missed It

In Case You Missed It
  • Tan Kiat How weighs in on viral video of Gan Kim Yong being ignored by passers-by in Punggol
  • PSP's Tan Cheng Bock turns 85; SDP's Paul Tambyah joins celebration at Teban Gardens
  • PM Wong urges voters to 'choose leaders of good character' in PAP's first party political broadcast
  • It is 'important for Singapore's democracy' that WP wins more seats, says Pritam in election broadcast
  • GE2025: PSP, RDU, SDP, PPP, PAR, NSP promise to push for policy changes if elected to Parliament in first political broadcast
  • 'Everyone has the right to express their feelings': WP candidates address four-cornered fight in Tampines GRC
  • PAP's Desmond Lee responds to opposition's calls for GST exemption, says 'we want to make it progressive'
  • 'A fresher Pritam Singh': Teo Chee Hean to Aljunied resident who mistook PAP's Faisal Abdul Aziz for WP chief
  • SDP leaders criticise GST hike and govt vouchers: 'Give you cup of water to put out fire'
This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.