Award Banner
Award Banner

Trial of ex-maid Parti Liyani was 'very, very difficult': Lawyer

Trial of ex-maid Parti Liyani was 'very, very difficult': Lawyer
PHOTO: YouTube/Home

The 10-month-long trial involving Indonesian domestic worker Parti Liyani was "very, very difficult", her lawyer Anil Balchandani said.

For one, there was "the sheer number of items that we had to deal with", said Mr Balchandani, who was acting pro bono.

They were also up against "a very tenacious set of prosecutors", not to mention "a very prominent family".

Ms Parti, 46, the former domestic helper of then Changi Airport Group and Surbana Jurong chairman Liew Mun Leong, was accused of stealing from his family. She was sentenced to 26 months' jail after she was found guilty by a district court in March last year.

Read Also
Maid acquitted of stealing over $34k worth of items from Changi Airport Group chairman's home
singapore
Maid acquitted of stealing over $34k worth of items from Changi Airport Group chairman's home

But, after maintaining her innocence for close to four years, she was finally acquitted last week in the High Court in a judgment that also raised questions about the motivation of Mr Liew and his family in lodging a police report against their former maid.

The Attorney-General's Chambers had said it was studying the judgment to assess what further action, if any, ought to be taken in light of Justice Chan Seng Onn's judgment.

Mr Balchandani's comments were made in an interview with the Humanitarian Organisation for Migration Economics (Home). The interview, uploaded on Home's website on Wednesday, was conducted two weeks before Justice Chan gave his verdict last Friday.

Ms Parti walked out a free woman on Tuesday after she was cleared of a fifth and last charge, for fraudulent possession of property. It came four days after she was acquitted of four charges for stealing about $34,000 worth of items, including clothing, bags and watches.

Mr Balchandani from Red Lion Circle law firm had been approached by Home at the end of 2017 after Ms Parti was slapped with four theft charges.

He had previously represented a migrant worker who was accused of a rash act and won an accquittal and had also secured probation for a youth who faced up to 20 years in jail and 15 strokes of the cane for drug trafficking charges.

He agreed to represent Ms Parti and put forward the case that she had not stolen any items: Some she had bought, some had been given to her, some had been discarded and some she had denied packing into the boxes meant to be shipped to Indonesia after she was fired.

LACK OF PHOTOS

In his interview with Home, Mr Balchandani also spoke about the low points of the trial, such as not having a "robust defence".

"One of the downsides of our case was that Parti... never really took a lot of photographs of herself, to identify, look... I had these items, I bought these items, I shared these photographs with whoever it was."

The most memorable moment was when the items were allowed to be presented before the appellate court to appreciate their condition - for example, the old DVD player and the outdated jewellery.

He said: "Each item had to be explained. The prosecution had its own side to the story, and we had to basically convince a judge that, look, why would someone steal junk?"

Read Also
singapore
'I forgive my employer': Ex-maid acquitted of stealing from CAG chairman hid ordeal from family

Mr Balchandani had also approached several senior lawyers for help, and he was grateful for their advice.

What struck him was Ms Parti's resolve. Beyond the pressures of the legal process, she also had a family to take care of.

He pointed out that if she had pleaded guilty in 2017, she would have been home by now, or even earlier.

"She could have restarted her life, continued working in another country and just thought about what happened in October 2016 (as just a bad dream)."

Mr Balchandani also gave credit to non-governmental organisations (NGOs).

"The bulk of the work is really done by a lot of people from Home and the other NGOs that step forward... the back-breaking activity (of) meeting with (those they are helping) every week, every month, giving them that hope that something good can happen."

This article was first published in The New Paper. Permission required for reproduction.

homepage

trending

trending
    'We are here to defy the odds': PAP's Aljunied team acknowledges tough fight, eyes return after 14 years
    'I am a fighter': Criminal lawyer Marshall Lim, PAP's candidate for Hougang SMC
    GE2025: Victor Lye and Jasmin Lau seen with SM Lee Hsien Loong at Ang Mo Kio GRC
    Multi-agency committee set up to ease inconveniences for residents moving into new BTO flats
    Van driver, 69, arrested for drink driving after crashing into 7 parked vehicles in Ang Mo Kio
    Mean and Green: We take a closer look at the Traffic Police's first electric patrol car
    From transport to co-living space: Sneak peek at Singapore's first MRT train hotel
    GE2025: PSP set to contest Marymount, Kebun Baru and Pioneer SMCs
    'Happy to be part of the team': PAP new face Valerie Lee joins walkabout on Pulau Ubin with Pasir Ris-Punggol MPs
    Two men fight each other at Johor checkpoint over allegation of cutting queue, probe on
    SG60 Baby Gift distribution kicks off: PM Wong pledges to do everything possible to support families
    Man, 77, discovered dead in Punggol flat; last seen over a week ago

Singapore

Singapore
    • 'Rest in peace, girl': Bouquets seen at the scene of River Valley fire where 10-year-old died
    • Calvin Cheng's comments regarding Gaza 'unacceptable and hurtful' to Malay/Muslim community: Masagos
    • GE2025: Why this 32-year-old is setting up a political party to contest East Coast GRC
    • Malaysian man jailed for assaulting bus driver over 11-minute wait at Tampines
    • Billion-dollar nickel scam: Ng Yu Zhi spent $7m on luxury cars he gave to wife, girlfriends
    • GE2025: Maliki Osman to be replaced by former news presenter Hazlina Abdul Halim in East Coast GRC
    • Fire engine's wheels get stuck in mud in Tengah estate
    • River Valley fire: Family of 10-year-old girl who died in blaze gather for last goodbye
    • Nee Soon GRC MP Faishal Ibrahim to contest in Marine Parade-Braddell Heights GRC
    • GE2025: AMK GRC heading for 3-cornered fight after 2 opposition parties fail to strike deal

Entertainment

Entertainment
    • Unreleased song by late Teresa Teng found in Japan, to be included in album this year
    • 'Cannot think of a better community of storytellers to tell our story': Local content announced to celebrate 'Singaporean-ness' for SG60
    • Marquee celebrates 6th anniversary on April 11 and 12 with DJs Dimitri Vegas and Steve Aoki
    • Gossip mill: Tanya Chua and Jane Zhang busk at Clarke Quay, top 10 Korean actors among overseas fans revealed, Ryoko Hirosue arrested for alleged assault
    • Brazilian DJ Alok fears visa removal for international artists in US
    • Josh Duhamel opens up about his love of living off-grid with family
    • Grey's Anatomy and Euphoria actor Eric Dane diagnosed with ALS
    • Soulja Boy ordered to pay former assistant more than $5.3 million in damages
    • Lady Gaga thinks Bruno Mars is a 'once-in-a-generation artist'
    • Meghan Trainor feels 'no shame' over using weight-loss medication

Lifestyle

Lifestyle
    • Changi Airport reclaims World's Best Airport title in 2025, 13th time at top spot
    • Hello, Sunny! Simonboy announces birth of son, shares scary moment where 'we lost his heartbeat'
    • 140 coffeeshops in Singapore offering SG60 promotions and discounts, here's what to expect
    • The rise of Chinese F&B brands in Singapore: What stirs Singaporeans' appetites?
    • Time travel, Singapore style: 60 landmarks that have shaped the Lion City
    • How couples should structure property ownership In Singapore (before it gets messy)
    • Would you visit a 'floating' mosque? 4 unique mosques for your bucket list
    • Questions I wish I could ask my friends with kids
    • Play tourist, stay local: 60 spots to make you fall in love with Singapore all over again
    • Wedding planning 101: Navigating guest lists, latecomers and in-law expectations

Digicult

Digicult
    • A $500 wake-up call: How the Samsung Galaxy Ring made me realise my stress
    • Monster Hunter Wilds producer explains how game has remained unique and fresh over 20 years
    • Google Pixel 9a: The best AI-centric phone under $800 in 2025?
    • Western intelligence agencies warn spyware threat targeting Taiwan, Tibetan rights advocates
    • Taiwan says China using generative AI to ramp up disinformation and 'divide' the island
    • Russian court fines Telegram app for refusal to remove anti-government content, TASS reports
    • One Beijing man's quest to keep cooking — and connecting with Americans — on camera
    • Nintendo Switch 2 to launch in June with US$449.99 price tag
    • Games in April: RPGs, racing and Ronaldo in a fighting game
    • Is it time to get a MacBook at a good price? The M4 MacBook Air says yes

Money

Money
    • Giant deal: Malaysian company to acquire Cold Storage and Giant supermarket chains in Singapore
    • Best fixed deposit rates in Singapore (April 2025): Minimum deposits from $500, rates up to 2.90%
    • 4 reasons new condos are launched at higher prices than you might expect
    • Best bank offers in Singapore (April 2025): Win a Lilo & Stitch-inspired Hawaii vacation, get up to 50% off flights, and more
    • Here are the biggest 3-bedroom condo units for under $2.1m in Singapore
    • Impact of tariffs on developing countries could be 'catastrophic', says UN trade agency
    • EU brainstorms on how to avert or brace for US tariffs as 90-day window opens
    • China hits back at Trump tariff hike, raises duties on US goods to 125%
    • Trump's tariff pause brings little relief as recession risk lingers
    • Asean bloc seeks dialogue with US on tariffs but won't retaliate

Latest

Latest
  • Trump says Ukraine talks may be going OK, but there is a time 'to put up or shut up'
  • New Zealand needs US as 'active' partner in Indo-Pacific, says NZ foreign minister
  • US State Department says deported Maryland resident 'alive and secure' in El Salvador
  • Gazans struggle to find water as clean sources become increasingly scarce
  • WHO members close to accord on tackling future pandemics, sources say
  • Brazil's Bolsonaro may need new surgery after being hospitalised
  • Protesting Hungarians mock Orban's anti-LGBT moves, saying 'Let's all be the same'
  • Trump spares smartphones, computers, other electronics from China tariffs
  • Skoda Kodiaq review: A large 7-seater SUV with a relatively small price tag

In Case You Missed It

In Case You Missed It
  • Ex-MP Lee Bee Wah introduces former MDDI director Goh Hanyan as potential candidate to Nee Soon residents
  • Robert Ng, son of late billionaire Ng Teng Fong, and 3 children to be designated as 'politically significant persons'
  • 'She should be with her family': Employer gives maid plane ticket, $800 to return to Myanmar and search for missing mum
  • 'He needed something to help him fight,' says man who bought Hokkien mee for dying patient
  • Thai woman struggles to evacuate during earthquake while her dog sleeps unfazed
  • Workers painting exterior of Geylang block discover man's skeletal remains in flat
  • 'New, younger' PAP team vows to reclaim WP-controlled Sengkang GRC, says Lam Pin Min
  • New face Jackson Lam 'very good on the ground' and will be asset to Parliament, says Shanmugam
  • Woman who publicised tips on how she evaded GST for luxury purchases fined $18k
This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.