Award Banner
Award Banner

Trump's Greenland bid stirs debate in China about what to do with Taiwan

Trump's Greenland bid stirs debate in China about what to do with Taiwan
A 3D-printed miniature model of US President-elect Donald Trump and the Greenland flag are seen in this illustration taken Jan 15, 2025.
PHOTO: Reuters

BEIJING/HONG KONG — For years, the US government has urged China to show "restraint" in pushing its claim on Taiwan and to drop military threats to bring the democratically governed island under its control.

Now — some Chinese commentators say — the power of that long-held US message has been undermined by the threats by US President-elect Donald Trump to take control of Greenland and the Panama Canal, by force if necessary. Trump takes office on Jan 20.

The implications of Trump's comments for US policy on Taiwan have been widely discussed on China's social media platforms in recent days and by foreign policy analysts.

While nothing in the military standoff over Taiwan is likely to change in the near-term, some say Trump's break with the norms of American diplomacy could create an opening for China.

One Chinese expert said Trump's first term in office signalled that he views foreign policy as transactional in nature, and suggested he may be amenable to a deal on Taiwan.

Zhao Minghao, a professor at the Institute of International Studies at the Fudan University in Shanghai, said Trump's threats to take Greenland, the Panama Canal and even Canada needed to be taken seriously.

"Besides that, we need to think about Trump's transactionalism, which he is serious about as well. Many in China still perceive Trump as a deal-maker, even on very tough issues like the Taiwan question," he said.

China's foreign ministry said it was "absurd" to try and link Greenland's status to Taiwan.

"The Taiwan issue is an internal Chinese matter, and how to resolve it is something for the Chinese people," it said in a statement sent to Reuters.

Taiwan's foreign ministry, asked whether Trump's comments could provide impetus to China creating trouble over Taiwan, said that the Republic of China, the island's official name, is a "sovereign and independent country".

"Any distortion of Taiwan's sovereign status will not change the status quo in the Taiwan Strait," it said in a statement.

The Trump transition team did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Read Also
Greenland important for the US, says Trump's pick for national security adviser
world
Greenland important for the US, says Trump's pick for national security adviser

China has maintained that Taiwan is part of its territory and has never renounced the use of force to bring the island under its control.

A limiting factor for Beijing is that the US is bound by law to provide Taiwan with the means to defend itself, although whether US forces would come to Taiwan's aid in the event of a war with China is unclear under a policy of "strategic ambiguity".

Trump offered strong support to Taiwan, including regularising arms sales, in his first term. But during the campaign last year, Trump said Taiwan should pay the US to be defended. Taiwan has repeatedly said it is committed to increasing its defence spending.

To be sure, the Taiwan question is vastly different to the Greenland, Canada or Panama Canal situations: in China's eyes, Taiwan is already legally Chinese territory whose destiny is to be "returned to the motherland". Taiwan rejects those claims.

Nevertheless, Trump's comments on Greenland have created a stir on Chinese social media, which is subject to censorship.

"If Greenland is annexed by the United States, China must take Taiwan," wrote Wang Jiangyu, a professor of law at City University of Hong Kong, on microblog site Weibo.

One commentator on a blog run by Chinese search engine Baidu said that if Trump does move on Greenland, China should "seize the opportunity to take back Taiwan".

"Trump seems to be serious, so we too should see what we could get from this," the person, writing as "Hongtu Shumeng" wrote.

Chen Fei, an associate professor at Central China Normal University's School of Politics and International Studies, wrote on Chinese news portal NetEase that just like Greenland for Trump, Taiwan was a core security interest for China.

But the two issues are not the same as what Trump is doing is directly threatening another country's sovereignty, he added.

"Taiwan is China's intrinsic territory and a pure internal Chinese matter. It has nothing to do with another country's sovereignty."

However, Bonnie Glaser, a Taiwan expert at the German Marshall Fund of the United States, said that for Chinese President Xi Jinping there were other factors carrying greater weight, especially his assessment of the country's military capabilities and the likely costs China would incur if it used force against Taiwan.

"I doubt that Beijing will draw parallels between Greenland and Taiwan," she said. "The Chinese believe that Taiwan is already and always has been part of China — they won't pay money for it and no government in Taiwan will agree to be bought.'"

Drew Thompson, a Senior Fellow at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies in Singapore and former US Department of Defence official, also said it was "quite preposterous" to think Trump's Greenland comments could embolden China's claims on Taiwan.

"But it does strike me that should President Trump refuse to...rule out the use of military force to achieve and protect US interests, I would think that type of statement and determination would serve to further deter Beijing to take any action that would prompt the US to take military action to protect Taiwan," he said.

"That's a pretty mighty deterrent for China."

Read Also
world
US says Trump administration will be obliged to continue probe of Israeli actions in Gaza

Source: Reuters

homepage

trending

trending
    Zhao Lusi seen with walking stick in 1st public appearance since revealing depression
    Zhang Shuifa jokes he still needs Terence Cao to look after him after 37 years
    Viral video of Singapore car-owner pumping Ron95 petrol in JB prompts reminder by Malaysian ministry to petrol stations
    'I never thought about having children': Qi Yuwu opens up about fatherhood and 3 situations he'd use corporal punishment
    Should you be concerned about ticks in Singapore? Study calls for greater vigilance
    Taking the train from Singapore to JB? The ultimate guide to KTM ticket prices, train schedule and more (2025)
    Buyer beware: Shopee customers lost nearly $400k to scammers in 2024
    China captures scam centre suspect with Thailand's help
    'It's a letter to my father': Jaspers Lai on writing script for CNY movie Number 2
    Jackson Wang hospitalised for sudden chest pains, pauses Got7's new album promotions
    Taiwan earthquake: Remains found identified as Singaporean man
    From elegant to unconventional: Red packet designs to look out for this Chinese New Year

Singapore

Singapore
    • 2 lucky punters share $13.3m Toto Reunion Draw jackpot
    • Fire engine, police van involved in separate traffic accidents on same day
    • GE2025 countdown officially starts as Singapore forms electoral boundaries review committee
    • 'Do you agree with criticisms of PAP?' PM Wong responds at youth dialogue
    • Over 3,000 names and NRIC numbers leaked due to CEA's IT system error
    • MOH revokes licence of Bishan clinic over medicine prescriptions, 2 doctors referred to HSA, SMC for investigation
    • 1 hospitalised, 60 evacuated following Punggol flat blaze early Sunday morning
    • Rare genetic condition leaves them constantly hungry, no matter how much they eat
    • 'Very worrying': Dog owner raises concerns over rat burrows treated with poison in Serangoon
    • 'It's so easy to access videos with sexual content': Some parents call for social media ban

Entertainment

Entertainment
    • 'Of all people, why me?' Hayley Woo written out of action scene in CNY movie due to Covid
    • 'We hope our efforts can bring some joy': Chen Liping and Ya Hui to sell buns for charity
    • 'Heart-wrenching arguments': Qi Yuwu and Joanne Peh open up about early years of marriage
    • Paris Fashion Week: Seventeen debuts new song; Jay Chou, Dylan Wang, Desmond Tan and more attend
    • Ashley Tisdale's daughter thought Zac Efron was her dad
    • Skai Jackson gives birth to her first child
    • Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds double down on request for gag order in legal battle
    • Kanye West boasts he's a billionaire with a net worth of $3.7b
    • Ed Sheeran will be first-ever international artist to perform in Bhutan
    • Kendrick Lamar to perform with SZA at Super Bowl Halftime Show

Lifestyle

Lifestyle
    • A different Chinese New Year: Woman opens up about spending the festive season in hospital
    • DBS/POSB launches limited-edition home scent reminiscent of mandarin oranges for CNY
    • Welcome to the future: This sleek new cafe at Beach Road has coffee and matcha on tap
    • Aye or nay? Balenciaga's $600 'barefoot' shoes divide opinion
    • Snake-inspired ways to celebrate the Lunar New Year
    • A different 2024 list: Toyota and BYD emerge on top
    • Why this underrated area could be Singapore's next up-and-coming property hotspot: A look at Seletar
    • Hyundai and Lasalle unveil Singapore-inspired Ioniq 6 art car
    • Touring a little-known affordable landed estate near Bedok Reservoir (from $2.85m)
    • Baby talk: From puree to solids - the different stages of food within baby's first year

Digicult

Digicult
    • Nintendo teases Switch 2 release in 2025 with first-look trailer
    • Accused of inflating Path of Exile 2 rank, Elon Musk beefs with gamer who asked him to prove skills
    • Black Myth: Wukong takes home Best Action Game at The Game Awards, beating Call of Duty, Helldivers
    • From truck driver to TikTok star: How social media changed Satoyu's life
    • Chinese AI startup DeepSeek overtakes ChatGPT on Apple App Store
    • Pope decries 'crisis of truth' in AI message to Davos forum
    • Instagram to restrict features for Singapore users suspected to be under 18
    • TikTok awaits Trump reprieve as China signals it is open to a deal
    • TikTok is restoring service, thanks Trump
    • TikTok stops working for US users, disappears from Apple, Google stores

Money

Money
    • GCB belonging to former president Ong Teng Cheong's family up for sale at $60m
    • Record 1,000 HDB resale flats hit $1m in 2024: Market anomaly or new norm?
    • What is halal investment? A guide to Singapore's buzzing Islamic finance scene
    • 6 reasons why some properties in Singapore are difficult to sell (even in a hot market)
    • Cost of health screen packages in Singapore (2025): Public and private hospitals, clinics and more
    • Why The Orie at Toa Payoh sold 86% of its 777 units in 1 weekend
    • Major Chinese port hit by congestion ahead of holiday, Trump tariff threat
    • China's frugal young adults accelerate saving, raising economic risks
    • 8 best personal loans in Singapore with lowest interest rates (January 2025)
    • Where can you find the most expensive HDB resale flats in Singapore?

Latest

Latest
  • Daily roundup: China captures scam centre suspect with Thailand's help — and other top stories today
  • Wife of Chinese national held in Philippines denies he is a spy
  • US puts Colombia tariff, sanctions threat on hold after deportations deal
  • Trump, at zenith of power, moves quickly to 'take over' Washington
  • Extreme fire danger grips Australia's southeast amid heatwave
  • Gambling tycoon abused in Thai jail after saying he spied for China, lawyers say
  • Turkey arrests 15 over deadly fire at ski resort, state media says
  • India's Republic Day marked by fighter jet formations, daredevil stunts
  • 2 children die in Mediterranean shipwreck, 17 rescued, NGO says

In Case You Missed It

In Case You Missed It
  • All travellers to Thailand, including Singaporeans, to fill in digital landing card from May 1
  • Police investigating petrol leak after mum and daughter found dead in car near Johor school
  • Woman claims she was nearly kidnapped near KSL City Mall; JB police say no reports lodged
  • Johor Bahru police deny taking bribes near Causeway
  • NUS student taken to hospital after falling from hostel
  • Cute but dangerous: Wild boar piglet spotted at Bukit Panjang
  • Condo concierge allegedly made off with over $47k of residents' money, stole items worth more than $2m
  • Patient in Malaysia clinic bled to death after doctor left for a drink; family awarded $1.82m in claims
  • 4 Singaporeans arrested in Geylang drug raid; over $1m worth of drugs seized
This website is best viewed using the latest versions of web browsers.